[ Home ] [ wiz / dep / hob / lounge / jp / meta / games / music ] [ all ] [  Rules ] [  FAQ ] [  Search /  History ] [  Textboard ] [  Wiki ]

/jp/ - Japan/Anime

Japanese Culture and Media
Email
Comment

File
Embed
Password (For file deletion.)

  [Go to bottom]   [Catalog]   [Return]   [Archive]

File: 1542728193564.jpg (154.38 KB, 800x524, 200:131, a3228.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

 No.28944[Last 50 Posts]

and write something about it.

Made a new one since the old one reached bump limit.

Old thread >>24509

 No.28949

Finished steis;gate 0, it was good.

 No.28951

>>28949
How do you think it holds up in comparison to the original? I agree with you that I thought it was a good anime but was nowhere near as good as the original, but mainly for reasons of animation and art quality, especially in the latter episodes. Overall, it started strong, slumped a bit in the middle and finished very satisfyingly

 No.28954

>>28949
If you found the Steins Gate series good, you should probably try Chaos;Head and Chaos;Child

Don't ever watch the anime for them though… Play the VN

 No.28955

Yeah, someone made a new one.

 No.28956

>>28954
>Don't ever watch the anime for them
That's likely true. I've watched nearly a thousand titles and Chaos;Head is among the VERY few that I have significant troubles remembering. All I recall is the main character being an otaku/hikki living in a freight container on a roof, which was depicted in a pretty comfy way. Also there were some murders, I think. And some… satellite or something fell onto some building in the end? All blurry.

 No.28957

Finally got around to watching Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica, which was pretty good once I got past the fact that it drags in the begining.
I new about the "big twist" going in so it was not shocking or anything but the writing still impressed me and overall the show was very creative in a lot of aspects. Haven't watched the movies but look forward to them.

I also marathoned Brynhildr in the Darkness, which I posted about in the craw thread on /lounge/. Even ignoring my amusement at the dub it still was a show that entertained me. Not bad, not great, but not bad at all.
I also watched both seasons of Psycho-Pass. Great cyberpunk/post cyber-punk anime. The psychological and detective stuff also hooked me. I will be watching the movie soon.

 No.28958

>>28956
The Chaos;Head anime is a mess, not only in terms of animation but the plot is barely coherent. Chaos;Child suffers from the same.
It surprises me that Steins;Gate was good considering how every other adaptation was complete horeshit.

 No.29004

>>28958
Robotics;Notes was actually pretty good and imo better than Steins;Gate.

 No.29005

finished a couple of shows and movies over the last two days.

Finished the second season of Space Dandy. It's a classic and I'm a little disappointed by how overlooked it is. For those of you that don't know, the director of Cowboy Bebop was involved. He's listed as Chief Director, though I think most of his job was directing the music and some overall direction/planning/supervising/writing a couple episodes each season. Natsume Shingo, the other director, seems to have been more hands-on involved in the actual production, but the show can't really even be considered that way. In some interview I was reading, Watanabe said that the idea behind Space Dandy was essentially a way to let individual talented animators in the industry show off and have fun. Basically, the show is sort of like a compilation of contracted anime doujins about Space Dandy and his crew. That's why the styles and consistency (not to mention narrative continuity) vary widely between episodes; each one has its episode director with a distinct style and flavour. The "planet/alien of the week" formula is just an excuse for the episode director to play around with an idea. Hopefully in the future there will be some sort of reevaluation of it, because I think it's criminally underrated.

I also finished Futari Wa Precure. It was fine, not much to say other then that I look forward to watching more Honoka in Max Heart.

 No.29006

>>29005
Everyone really liked space dandy when it came out, but people for some reason forgot about it. It's also one of my favorites.

 No.29007

>>29006
It was ok, not much to say about it.

 No.29008

>>28958
It honestly surprises me that people think steins;gate was good. It was a chore to watch. Most of the time high rated anime I can at least appreciate but I just didn't enjoy it at all. The same thing has only happened to me with Akira. I have actually watched that about three times now I think, every time not enjoying it one bit and then forgetting it, then I read someone raving over how great it is and wonder if maybe I misjudged it and go to watch it again and it puts me to sleep just like it did the last time.

 No.29009

>>29007
Yeah, the reason everyone forgot about it was because it was just pure entertainment for the moment. It's not the kind of show that you delve into discussing the plot twists and character arcs, it's just a really fun watch.

 No.29010

>>29005
For the movies, I watched Children Who Chase Lost Voices. It was the last Shinkai movie I had left to see, and it wasn't good. It's the least Shinkai movie and the closest to a Ghibli film he's gotten, which is why I think it's his worst. He's good at mood pieces and bad at writing, and Lost Voices is the opposite.

The other one I saw was Mirai no Mirai, the new Hosoda film. I actually think it's his best one. There's typical Hosoda fetish scenes in it (pregnancy and furryshit) but those are short and done with in the first 20 minutes or so. I actually really didn't like it at first because of how insufferable the children are and all the Abe propaganda, but once it starts getting to the time warping, the movie actually gets pretty good.

 No.29011

>>29007
>>29009
There's actually a lot to discuss, just not in terms of overarching narrative. But there are some fairly deep episodes, like the episode that takes place in Limbo or the Groundhog Day episode.

 No.29012

>>29011
Honestly, the only episodes I vaguely remember were the zombie and school musical one.

 No.29013

>>29005
Stop calling shows from several years ago "classic".

 No.29014

>>29013
Is Madoka not a classic?

 No.29015

>>29014
Something from the nearest decade cannot be considered a classic by definition. "Classic" is something that is vastly remembered after a long time. Mere several years don't count as that.
Speaking of anime, I personally believe nothing that came after 2000 can be called a classic. And some people in fact argue that even the 90s' shows don't deserve that term yet.

 No.29016

>>29015
>classic
noun
1.
a work of art of recognized and established value.

Nothing relating to time there.

 No.29017

>>29016
What about the "established value" part? For something to be established, it has to have been around for a while.

 No.29018

>>29016
Said "recognition and establishment" requires time to be valid. Something that gets favorable "critical acclamation" yet is forgotten soon after is not a classic.

And as far as anime fandom is concerned, unironically calling something from 2010s a "classic" is like showing off that you're extremely new.

 No.29019

>>29017
not really, established is past tense, so that only implies that it already happen. no exact time requisite

>>29018
>Said "recognition and establishment" requires time to be valid.
not really. how much time do you need? what's the benchmark for something to be consider classic? if it's 30 years, why is it not a classic at 29 years? and if it's 20, why not 19? a year difference wouldn't change the quality, ergo the essence of a classic seems to be intrinsic. there's actually an argument about this exactly in hyouka. there's also the term "instant classic," you know.

>And as far as anime fandom is concerned, unironically calling something from 2010s a "classic" is like showing off that you're extremely new.

most people would argue madoka is a modern classic.

 No.29020

>>29019
>established is past tense, so that only implies that it already happen. no exact time requisite
"Established" in the context of the definition you provided is an adjective, not a verb. Therefore it doesn't have tense.

https://www.macmillandictionary.com/us/dictionary/american/established

 No.29021

>>29020
fair enough, but in terms of pop culture, especially anime, reevaluation isn't common. if you consider gigantor a classic, bear in mind that nobody watches gigantor anymore, so the "established value" part tends to happen relatively soon after a show actually airs.

 No.29022

>>29021
also, you can be as anal about the definition as much as you want, but i didn't even originally intend to insinuate your definition. the fact is the word classic is pretty commonly used as a synonym of a word like "tour de force," just generally the idea of an outstanding achievement. linguistically i'm not wrong, it's only incorrect with respect to the categorical pedant.

 No.29023

>>29004
I barely remember anything about Robotic;Notes aside from that scene where the succubus who used the mechanical legs dies
>>29012
you don't remember the death one? it was one of my favorites, could perfectly be a separate artsy anime short.

 No.29024

>>29018
>And as far as anime fandom is concerned
I'm not sure why anyone here would give a fuck what they think.

 No.29025

>>29021
I don't understand your argument. Are you saying that only new anime can be considered "classic" because older shows are relatively unpopular?

>>29022
What? >>29016 was the definition you posted, right?

 No.29026

>>29025
I just pulled that definition off of a search that seemed to be related to what you're talking about.

>Are you saying that only new anime can be considered "classic" because older shows are relatively unpopular?

The argument is what is actually a classic if nobody cares about it? If the idea is that a classic must stand the test of time, then how come so many classic anime don't? Do you think anyone really cares about Future Boy Conan?

 No.29027

Of course a simple thread about posting when you finish an anime gets dragged down by people debating the definition of a word defined vaguely.

 No.29028

>>29026
So you don't stand by that definition then? Can you give a more accurate definition so that I can understand what you're talking about?

>If the idea is that a classic must stand the test of time, then how come so many classic anime don't?

If a show doesn't stand the test of time, it's not a classic. And did anyone even bring up Future Boy Conan?

 No.29029

>>29028
>And did anyone even bring up Future Boy Conan?
Many people that know about it consider it to be a classic. It's also hard to argue that it's not, considering it's a Miyazaki show. Many people also haven't seen it.

>So you don't stand by that definition then? Can you give a more accurate definition so that I can understand what you're talking about?

I was just using the term synonymously with the phrase "tour de force." This is pretty common thing in movie commercials when they list one-liners from positive reviews.

 No.29030

>>29029
I understand now. We are working off different definitions and talking about different things. I think that you're likely to run into further arguments if you continue to use the word "classic" while working off a non-standard definition. I suggest that you use "tour de force" off the bat instead, so that people will immediately know what you're talking about. But that's just friendly advice. In the sense that you mean "classic," I agree with your posts.

 No.29031

>>29030
fair enough.

 No.29036

File: 1543653781564.gif (606.78 KB, 720x405, 16:9, 321321321.gif) ImgOps iqdb

Watched all of Black Lagoon in two sittings.
I gotta say this is the most wanna be hardcore but instead totally just an edge fest anime I have ever seen….and I loved it. The edge cut right into my soul it's so ridiculous and unintentionally hilarious I can't say iv ever bore witness to something anime related of this caliber before.
Every strong character outside of like two people is a succubi which only makes it funnier. If you can handle copious amounts of cursing and can laugh at accidental cringe I would highly recommend it since it's rather short and honestly pretty unique.

 No.29037

File: 1543662152265.jpg (2.07 MB, 2560x1440, 16:9, 687156.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I just finished watching Dimension W.

Overall it was absolute garbage. I regret forcing myself to finish the 12 episodes. It literally felt like I was watching a Marvel remake or something. The plot was Hollywood-tier and totally convoluted. The art style was forgettable. The characters were bland even by anime standards.

I liked the opening song and the ending song as well to a lesser extent.

Anyway, I recommend that absolutely nobody watch this.

The only reason I picked this up was because the same studio that made flip flappers was involved, which caught my interest. I haven't read the source material but I'm certain that it's garbage. Overall I rate it 4/10. Yes I'm giving it a numerical rating you contrarian pseudointellectual.

 No.29038

File: 1543662379060.jpg (439.19 KB, 2048x2048, 1:1, d8af193b-4cc0-4083-9684-3d….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I watched Girlish Number. Overall it was mediocre.

The characters and their interactions were quite bland. Some of the industry caricatures were humourous, but overall the characters were a major weak point. This is particularly fatal in a SOL series such as this.

I liked the colour palette and some of the outfits were cute. That's about the only good thing I have to say. I suppose the cynical take on the industry was somewhat entertaining, at least initially.

Also I ship chitose x gojou

What did you think of girlish number?

 No.29039

>>29038
I liked chitose's character because she was an awful human being. That's about all I liked to be honest. Difficult to be both industry criticism and CGDGT at the same time.

 No.29040

Full Metal Panic: Invisible Victory.
I don't remember most of the characters, and this sequel seems to ignore how long it was since last series. The comedy is gone and they pushed the Sagara x Chidori relationship much more. Overall it wasn't bad, I didn't drop it - where it lacks comedy it had some nice mech fights.

 No.29041

File: 1543670727148.jpg (2.91 MB, 6393x4081, 6393:4081, Bakuon!!.full.2008675.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Alright I just finished watching Bakuon.

Overall it was bad. Writing was definitely the crippling weak point here. The novelty of succubi riding bikes wore off quickly. Certainly if the viewer is a motorcycle owner then they might derive more entertainment from some of the 'inside' jokes about motorbikes. Even so, each episode was painfully boring. I don't know how they managed this when the focus is on riding sporty motorcycles. The characters themselves were extremely bland and unlikable. It took me months to slowly watch each of the 12 episodes when the impulse struck me to put one on. Like I said, the novelty wears off very fast.

Production quality was unremarkable and the music was bad.

Honestly I would have found it more entertaining if they cranked up the ecchi even more than they did. It is extremely rare for me to have this view but some of the characters certainly have sex appeal.

The strongest aspect of this series was certainly humour. There were many times when I laughed out loud at the gags. However, this did not adequate compensation for the time I spent. It's disappointing because I liked the premise of this series.

 No.29042

>>29039
I enjoyed the stark contrast between the saccharine art style and the actual writing/characters

 No.29043

>>29036
Black Lagoon is cool, the arc about the two siblings was my favorite.
Also the engrish in that anime is hilarious during the Japan arc.

 No.29050

>>29037
Fuck I had this downloaded because I enjoy sci-fi anime and it looked ok, but your post makes me want to delete it.

 No.29064

>>29036
A similar show to Black Lagoon is jormungand.
Main character is a child solderer and a megalomaniac arms dealer. It also gets edgy as fuck in assuming ways.

 No.29065

>>29064
Something made me hate and drop Jormungand absolutely, while I gave Black Lagoon a watch until the end.

Jormungand struck me as "yet another anime where the females are crazy and lesbo and the best because it's cool and that's what you guys want, right?"
Can't put my finger on it.
Oh wait, I can, I remember that fucking shootout scene in Episode 3 or something where he used a grapple hook to pull the MC out of harm's way - the silly thing was that they were shooting at themselves in the open from point blank range for like 20 seconds before he grappled him away from like 50m and from behind cover. Ass-pulls the show.

 No.29069

>>29037
I enjoyed it but felt that it really needed more time/ep to develop everything. Storylines felt rushed and overall nothing felt satisfying because of the pacing problems.
I think that is my only real complaint about the show.

 No.29080

>>29065
I should rewatch Jormungand, I barely remember anything from it. Aside from the obvious twist with the new character in season 2 and the stupid ending.

 No.29085

>>29064
>>29065
>>29069
Another "similar" one is Canaan btw.

 No.29087

Finished Arslan Senki. It was okay I guess, but I feel like I've seen a lot of shows like this by now. Standard military fantasy show. Pretty heavy handed and uninspired themes and overall plot with lazy worldbuilding. Kind of relies heavily on the "guys pop out from the cliffs with arrows" gag that is already too common in these types of things, but some of the tactics were interesting. It's very visually impressive though. The fight choreography was also pretty good for an anime. I think I would have preferred an older and more confident MC. He kept pissing me off by being overly weak and indulgent and I get that that's kind of the whole point, people follow him because he's a good guy, not like the other kings who are evil, but honestly it would have been more fun if he wasn't such a naive goody goody. It also followed the annoying trend with anime to not have any sort of plot resolution. Fucking everything is based off some long ass manga but nothing ever gets high enough ratings to make it to the end of the story. Oh well, it wasn't a particularly interesting story anyway.

 No.29101

File: 1544309851707.jpg (46.34 KB, 800x450, 16:9, tw.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Watched the Boku no Hero Academia movie. It was fun, like a movie based on a running shounen manga should be. Tons of fanservice, popular characters gets to shine and really good animation, Bones never fails to deliver.
Had a good time watching it. I can't ask for more when it comes to these kind of movies.

 No.29126

File: 1544582073772.jpg (412.28 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, Girls Last Tour.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Just watched Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou (succubi Last Tour). It was amazing. So much emotion packed into each episode and yet very comfy. The last 2 episodes were somehow really intense yet so similar to the rest of the show. It's hard to even think of anything bad about it. Would really recommend to anybody looking for something comfy.

 No.29127

I couldn't remember what C³ was about so I watched it again. It was bitchin. But seriously I know why I couldn't remember it. It is really mediocre and nothing special at all. I also hated how bland the action scenes were. It wasn't bad. Bad would be memorable. Just bland.
C is pretty lame, yet I ended up watching it twice. Hopefully this time I remember I didn't enjoy it and not have to watch it a third time.

 No.29129

Finished Made in Abyss, shouldnt have judged it by its cover. Its a great series, characters were surprisingly well written, especially Reg, almost forgot that anime can be this good.

 No.29130

>>29129
Read the manga if you enjoyed the anime, the series basically ends just when its getting good.

 No.29133

Just finished watching Love Live Sunshine. It was rather predictable most the time but I enjoyed it. I cried at the end and I don't even know why.

 No.29153

>>29130
will do

 No.29187

File: 1544982968151.jpeg (127.79 KB, 848x911, 848:911, hanamaru.jpeg) ImgOps iqdb

It was a few days ago but I finished Hanamaru Kindergarten. Decent, not really full of anything too interesting. There is some nice comedy in it.

 No.29191

Finally finished some of those "best of all time" anime where it's an oddity that I've not seen them:
Death Note - Very strong for the first 15 episodes, but then it really does drop the ball and stays pretty average up until the ending 2 episodes. I liked the premise, in particular the fact that Light wasn't some repressed bully victim but an ultra-chad, made it a bit more compelling. Got a question for you posters, did your opinion of him change over time? I initially thought he was righteous (even if the most self-conceited man on the planet), and then once he started killing people only because they were threatening him, I felt like that was a move to make the viewer hate him, but I just saw it as collateral damage and justifiable. Maybe it's just autism and refusal to change my opinion.
Attack on Titan - I didn't get it. Simple as that. Finished the whole first season because I had nothing else to do, but I really found it uncompelling. Characters were boring as hell, pacing was questionable, so was the premise, etc. The action was good enough, and the only thing I can really commend it for is the art and music.
Kaiji - Solid, probably my new favourite anime. Can see why some people would be turned away by the art style, but I think it works really well in making everything look harsh. Great writing, probably one of the best OSTs of an anime I can think of, you really care for Kaiji, and I think it was great how harsh they were willing to beat him down. He didn't always have to win because "he's the MC", he really does take some huge losses at times. I didn't really like the pachinko arc, not sure why all things considered, I think it just went on a bit long, and I had no qualms with the ending, but I can see how some people with. Still, I really didn't like how it also somewhat indirectly said "read the manga lol" because Kaiji said something about how he'd finally defeat Hyoudo, but never does

 No.29194

>>29191
I liked Light all the way through, hated the ending. I wish it just ended when L died. Granted I never read the manga.

 No.29195

>>29191
Attack on Titan is so freaking boring. I had to force myself to finish season 3 and the only reason I did so was because I hoped something would happen that would peak my interest (spoilers, nothing ever did). The show is so convoluted, so lacking character depth and so uncompelling I actually find it amazing that an anime based around giants that eat you could be this uninteresting.

The show desperately wants to have meaningful character depth but it just fails on every level. I can hardly even recall what happens or who died even though it has only been a couple of months since I watched it. If it wasn't for the fact that season one of AoT became a huge meme in the states entirely for the giants eating humans scenes I wonder how small and niche the show would have ended up.

I accidently had the greater storyline spoiled for me and it honestly makes the whole show even worse so I would not recommend any deep spoilers.

 No.29196

>>29195
The manga is much better. The anime skips minor details that end up becoming extremely important later in the series, so it'll just look like an asspull to anime watchers when it becomes important. If you can get past the terrible art at the beginning of the series and read past season 3 material, you'll probably really like it.

 No.29207

>>29195
I have never understood why people do this. It's usually easy to tell a bad anime from a good one in just a few episodes.

 No.29208

File: 1545148177405-0.jpg (140.25 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, [HorribleSubs] Chuukan Kan….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1545148177405-1.jpg (48.03 KB, 225x317, 225:317, 93145.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Hilarious "Parody" of the Kaiji anime. They take Japanese business, drinking and eating serious and accentuate it with many Zawas and the usual pace of the Kaiji stories. The storytelling itself is simple slice of life, but that's why I liked it, very relaxing to watch.

 No.29209

>>29208
Hey I'm watching that too, its pretty fun.
I feel like its rare to see an anime actually centered on wageslaving adults.

 No.29220

File: 1545196653170.png (894.44 KB, 1280x710, 128:71, K-on-genderbent-k-on-35261….png) ImgOps iqdb

I recently finished watching the K-ON series (even including the ura-on specials).

It was alright. To my surprise, the most enjoyable aspect was the comedy. This is unusual for me. A lot of the gags were frequently quite funny.

Azusa was my favourite character and I honestly feel like she was the writer's intended 'actual' main character, as opposed to Yui. god I wish I had long pretty twintails hair like Azusa. God I wish I was Azusa

Production quality was solid, as one would expect. Although I can't stand the colour palette. I don't really like any form of rock (so I'm biased in this respect) but some of the songs (ie. character songs) were nice and I actually put a few on my music playing device.

Okay, having stated the above, I found the series mediocre overall. I try to ignore expectations going into anything, but despite that I couldn't help but feel mildly disappointed. K-ON was not the timeless classic I had been lead to expect. It wasn't any better than your average seasonal SOL. I am bewildered by how it has received so much praise.

For a series as long as K-ON it's amazing how little character development actually took place. Every character felt so bland and lacked any depth and nuance. This is fatal to any SOL, especially with a long episode count. Overall direction was also unremarkable and unworthy of any praise.

Consistent 6/10 and totally forgettable. It was comfy I guess.

basically you have shit taste if you really liked K-ON and should watch more SOL

 No.29221

>>29220
K-ON is one of those series I have on hold due to how hyped it seems to be. I'm wary of it not living up to expectations I have set, but one of these days I'll have to bite the bullet and download it.

 No.29222

>>29220
I think one of the main draws was that it was among the "first" CGDCT SoL. Since then many other SoL have surpassed it though.

 No.29223

File: 1545200446031.jpg (236.63 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, K-On!! - 22 - Exams! (BD, ….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

>>29220
>It wasn't any better than your average seasonal SOL.
Except it was released way before seasonal SOLs became a thing.
In fact they did become a thing exactly because K-On got so popular.
It was the first successful Kirara adaptation which drew studios' attention to other works published in Kirara magazine.
In other words, if it weren't for K-On (and Lucky Star too, and also Azumanga way before that) you now wouldn't be getting your seasonly dose of cute girIs doing cute things, so better show some respect nigger.

 No.29237

>>29194
I really didn't like L's death either but I just kind of saw it as an inevitability, right from the first couple episodes once he approached Light and became a huge threat, but I really didn't like the American who was meant to replace him, and I felt the ending was appropriate, since I just didn't really think he'd succeed, I personally interpreted it as the fact that humans can never be God, and even if Kira's (godly) justice may have been more effective than the standard human one, but ultimately it failed because the man in charge couldn't control it

 No.29250

Finished the first season of Oreimo recently. I haven't been this happy while watching an anime in years. The characters are fun and lovable and it's all around just a good time. I highly reccomend it!

 No.29253

>>29237
>I really didn't like the American who was meant to replace him
This. This is what killed the ending for me. The interpretation you posted is fine and would have been satisfactory for me, I think, if the circumstances were a little different. But I felt like the handling of that whole arc was just atrocious. If I stopped watching around the point I mentioned in my last post, I would have enjoyed the show more overall. Honestly either of them dying would have been fitting to me, I just saw the show as a battle of wits between Light and L. Having this random kid come in and do a way better job in a matter of episodes just killed it, and even felt disrespectful to everything that came before.

 No.29265

File: 1545448255425.jpg (773.78 KB, 1920x1280, 3:2, Shigatsu.wa.Kimi.no.Uso.fu….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Just finished watching Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso.

Let me start with what I think is it's most noteworthy characteristic: the direction. This was very well directed, and I think this is fundamentally why it is so widely praised. It was superior in other technical respects as well. I liked the character designs. Production quality was solid. The first OP and the second ED were my favourite songs.

Having said the above, I didn't really enjoy Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso personally. It never engaged me on an emotional level. This is a matter of personal taste so don't get butthurt. I didn't like or engage with any of the characters. The blonde homewrecker in particular I found rather unlikable. Generally speaking I don't enjoy het romance. Again, personal taste; this paragraph is basically a diary entry.

In my experience there are two fundamental mechanisms by which an anime achieves greatness. 1. Emotional engagement & 2. Artistic merit. Having failed to satisfy mechanism #1 I sought to evaluate #2. However in this respect this anime falls short. In my view it is devoid of creativity. Both visually and musically it was not unique or memorable. Artistic merit is something a value tremendously, personally.

Overall this was a 7/10 for me. I tried to keep my expectations low going in. I don't regret watching it.

The direction was excellent. However this is unfortunately the only noteworthy aspect of Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso.

 No.29266

>>29265
I forgot to mention that I found the last episode somewhat anticlimatic.

ALSO I completely forgot to mention that I found the pacing a bit too fast for my liking. I think I would've enjoyed Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso more if the pacing was slower.

I am drunk btw sorry for any grammatical errors

 No.29285

File: 1545664529126-0.jpg (84.88 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, [AniDL] Qualidea Code-08-[….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1545664529126-1.jpg (85.49 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, [AniDL] Qualidea Code-03-[….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1545664529126-2.jpg (86.02 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, [AniDL] Qualidea Code-01-[….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Finished Qualidea Code. Otherwise known as QUALITY Code. I tried to watch this as it aired but dropped it within a minute. I really regret that now, after giving it another shot. Watched it again for the QUALITY, but it very quickly became something I watched because it was fucking good. Why didn't anyone tell me it was this fucking good?
Characters have depth, they're explored and develop, their interactions are lively and satisfying, and they're the strongest part of the entire thing, and so it really pays off when things happen to them.
The plot itself, the main flaw is that it's a dumb idea. However, it's pulled off pretty much as best as you ever could pull it off, things are developed and created around the plot which make it so that the central things that happen don't matter so much as the effects it has on the characters.
No joke this is great. Although with the caveat that the animation really was bad. Soundtrack was good, but more importantly it was used really well.

 No.29293

File: 1545772257269-0.jpg (84.73 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, 05 - Crimson Pulse_00:00:4….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1545772257269-1.jpg (180.4 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, 06 - A Lying Smile_00:08:1….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1545772257269-2.jpg (110.98 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, 11 - Remaining Posibility_….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Ange Vierge:
Very simple and straightforward, but done effectively. The succubi are all introduced right away, but then the show takes its time to go through them and develop them properly, which is nice. It aims for silly fun, and the succubi are often just bakas. I thought it was fun and enjoyable.

 No.29297

90s anime sure has some … interesting background music choices. you could easily do without any music for most of the scenes, yet they felt the need to add stuff. especially when it plays for minutes on end looping, yeah it's a beach scene, you don't need the music for the whole thing… complete saturation with stale sounds

 No.29334

File: 1546121683970-0.jpg (94.13 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, kg1.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1546121683970-1.png (307.38 KB, 853x480, 853:480, kg3.png) ImgOps iqdb

Finished Kakegurui and I have mixed feelings about it.
On the one hand I appreciated the unique aesthetic the anime went for. That mix of eroticism, jazzy soundtrack, the color red and over the top reactions, but on the other as a gambling anime it falls short. All the gambles are basically the same, and are so far fetched that its basically impossible for the audience to even be able to predict or logically deduce how will Yumeko pull it off. Everything happens pretty much offscreen until Yumeko decides to reveal her master plan that she was crafting from the very beggining.
Like every gamble in the anime is basically bad guy lets Yumeko win at first>she starts losing>bad guy goes on a ramble about how she's just playing on their hands>suddenly Yumeko makes a comeback>MASAKA>Yumeko proceds to explain how the other person was the one playing along her the entire time.
But despite all of that I enjoyed it, I was entertained for the 12 episodes it lasted so I would give it a 5 or 6 at least. Will watch the second season.

 No.29342

File: 1546157328316.png (1.06 MB, 1366x768, 683:384, 7.png) ImgOps iqdb

Irozuku Sekai no Ashita kara

The first 8 episodes were absolutely incredible - generally relaxing, peaceful and very comfortable atmosphere but during several important moments the visuals, music and story all came together to form a tidal wave of emotions that completely entranced me and made me snap out of it seconds later with tears running down my cheeks. Ive never heard Yoshiaki Dewa's name before but will definitely remember it from now on, the entire OST including the OP and ED is outstanding. Id like to keep going with the praise, but the anime has 13 episodes in total, sadly.

In episode 9 romance fully enters the stage with Shou's confession, and pretty much remains the focus of the story to its unfortunate detriment (not helped by the ending, felt like a pretty big letdown after essentially a 5-episode-buildup). Some impactful moments happen during these 5 episodes too, but they just dont feel the same and are nowhere near as good. The anime is very good overall, but that to me is the main problem - if judged only by the first 8 episodes it would be excellent, I would even go so far as to nominate it the Best of Fall 2018. But, nonetheless, I really enjoyed it and will be rewatching it periodically. Definitely recommended.

 No.29367

File: 1546400207987-0.jpg (98 KB, 1244x700, 311:175, 01.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1546400207987-1.jpg (64.01 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, 02.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Finished Sirius the Jaeger.
It was bad. It starts with some strong first episodes which have some very nice animation and action, but it quickly falls apart, mostly in the middle. The series goes from simple vampire killing business to family melodrama and esoteric mumbo jumbo that barely makes sense. They are constantly trying to make the viewer emotional over these characters but its hard to do it when you barely give a shit about them.
Also the animation which is really nice for the first few episodes goes to shit halfways through, and the action which was one of the things that got me hooked turns very dull on later episodes. The final fight is specially underwhelming, considering that a fight on the first episode againts a minor character is much better in every sense.
I would only recommend this if you're thirsty for vampire anime.

 No.29375

Haruhi Suzumiya franchise
upon reflection for 2006 it was pretty mad just how viral it was, most shows these days don't even have that, just maybe a reference to something in a single frame for screenshots
anyhow, good show, really no major complaints, didn't like Asahina much on the whole, I liked how Kyon became held a bit more of an active role in the Disappearance and the Endless Eight
speaking of which that was absolutely terrible and I'm not sure who at kyoani thought it was a good idea
great soundtrack, probably one of the best I can think of
whole thing was solid, except that spinoff with Yuki as a generic shoujo MC, which was terrible even on its own merits
not articulate but these were my thoughts

 No.29377

Done with season 1 of Kaiji thanks to seeing it mentioned on here. I give it a "highly recommended" stamp. I liked it a lot and I'm gonna watch season 2 soon. Especially if you are into competitive games, there are some good tidbits on strategizing and reading your opponent. It was cool to see them go in depth on games that seem simple on the surface, but offer room for creative strategies.

The character of Kaiji was also very well done, he was smart and ballsy, maybe too much for his own good. He was also allowed to lose instead of winning everything in the end like lots of anime, so there was genuine tension in a lot of parts about whether he would succeed, his opponent would catch on to his tricks, etc. And there was good development in his character.

Art and music I felt were very well done. Vid related is one of the tracks I liked the most, but they're all really good and fit the atmosphere of the show perfectly. I've heard some people are put off by the artstyle but I found it very expressive.

 No.29380

Dropped Texhnolyze after 2 eps. Some of you will call me dumb and that I "just don't get it", but it really felt like a random compilation of deliberately cryptic clips put together, there seemed to be no story of any sort. Though SEL did seem a bit like that initially, it didn't feel 100% random, there was enough information to keep the viewer interested. Just felt like a flashier and more violent MWAMC

 No.29381

>>29380
You made the right choice. There is literally no story the entire way through it. It's the definition of all style no substance. It was a chore to finish.

 No.29382

>>29380
I remember feeling that way when I watched Ghost in the Shell Innocence

 No.29390

>>29380
congrats on not being a pseudointellectual neckbeard

 No.29392

Finished Inuyashiki
Generally I dislike superheroes, but I quite liked this, story and pacing was good and all, biggest complaint was Hiro, he was perhaps the most empty antagonist I've ever seen, just killing people for fun, it's not even like he's a repressed bully victim or anything, just extremely bland

 No.29394

>>29334
Dropped after 4 eps
I tried my absolute best to judge it on its own merits and not "how does it compare to Kaiji", but it completely falls apart on its own merits, nothing good, even the BDSM overtones which would perhaps keep my retard mind that hasn't matured past 16 years complacent for 12 episodes, but I just couldn't bear any more, I only watched 4 to see how the arc ended, but that was too much
could not recommend that terrible display to anyone

 No.29404

Finished Gunsmith Cats. Really fun anime, though I would've loved to see the characters being fleshed out more, though that's probably down to the constraint of only 3 episodes. The art style was very pleasing, but that's probably because I like the old 90's era animation.

 No.29409


 No.29410

>>29394
>BDSM
Why do I keep hearing about this degenerate shit everywhere.

 No.29416

>>29410
can't answer for other places you've heard it, but with the scrawny beta MC (or secondary MC next to Yumeko) being shown as a human chair in probably the first 6 minutes makes it rather blatant I'd say

 No.29417

File: 1547134896271.jpg (190.98 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, mpv-shot0026.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

>>29416
I rechecked, 1 minute 40 seconds
when you see this in the first 2 minutes it leaves an impression

 No.29438

File: 1547367849102.jpg (114.98 KB, 723x1024, 723:1024, ce707b838619223b45d6dc7423….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

fucking dropped.
Made it to episode 6. What a steaming pile of garbage.

I seriously cannot believe you people actually praise this. It is mediocre at best.
>muh middle school romance
Is poorly written and directed, and not emotionally engaging in any way. Production quality is awful in every respect. The art style and character designs are hideous.

You have absolute SHIT TASTE if you liked Tsuki ga Kirei

 No.29442

File: 1547379029013.jpg (649.07 KB, 2160x1920, 9:8, Hai-to-Gensou-no-Grimgar.A….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Let me preface this by clarifying that I am huge sucker for classical fantasy settings such as this. I've always been into fantasy novels and role-playing games. I used to play tabletop dungeons and dragons a ton like 9 years ago back when I willingly sought out social interaction with humans. I would always ALWAYS play rogue characters so this definitely contributed to my enjoyment of Hai to Gensou no Grimgar. (The main character is a rogue)

Alright, let's start with the bad. Overall characterization in this is poor and most of the cast is very bland as well as unlikable. The best and most developed characters are Mari and Haruhiro. Maybe the rest of the cast gets better treatment in the source material (which I will hopefully read eventually). This series was only 12 episodes, disappointingly. Which is a reasonable excuse for poor characterization. To their credit, the plot was self-contained and loose ends were wrapped up well. However, I think I would have enjoyed a 24 ep series much more with more character development and richer world building. I also didn't really like the character designs. Except for Mari- her hair is so pretty!! god I wish I was Mari

Both the OP and ED were composed of panning stills. Very lazy. When I watched episode 1 I thought it was a production issue that they'd update with something better (I was wrong).

This is a matter of personal opinion, but I really did not like the OST. Music is a major part of this anime. It is used very frequently, not just during action scenes but frequently vocal songs are played in the background while the characters talk. A diverse array of vocal songs are played often. The problem is that it is all j-rock. Personally I don't like rock as a genre, and generally I found that it was totally unsuitable for the setting. Would have preferred a totally different style of OST. That said, some of the background nonvocal stuff was nice.

Some of the VAs in this were pretty good. Haruhiro's voice was really nice and he looked really attractive in his leather armour.

. Alright, what's the best thing about this anime? The background art (not character design). The setting looks absolutely gorgeous. EVERY FRAME looks amazing. I was pausing all the time just to admire the art. Huge enjoyment was derived from this. It reminds me of watercolour paints which I used to use a lot.
Like I said before, I'm a huge sucker for classical fantasy role-playing worlds. If you are too then you will probably enjoy this. My personal enjoyment was 8/10, but a neutral perspective might be lower than that.

 No.29447

File: 1547503046765-0.jpg (965.31 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, ACCA 13-ku Kansatsu-ka s1e….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1547503046765-1.jpg (969.89 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, ACCA 13-ku Kansatsu-ka s1e….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1547503046765-2.jpg (1.1 MB, 1920x1080, 16:9, ACCA 13-ku Kansatsu-ka s1e….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

This was really good and comfy. Back when it was airing some sjws tried to stir a drama around it ("muh natsee uniforms" and all) but afaik no one cared much. Still, that was when I decided to watch it, and now finally got down to checking it out since the BDs came out and all.

The authors obviously tried their best at imitating the 80s anime vibe - the characteristic color palette, drawing style and effects, the soundtrack (a mix of chillout jazz and 80s synth), and the overall noir-like atmosphere should appeal greatly to the connoisseurs.

I really liked the world building, which at first seemed pretty ridiculous and barebones, but then started unveiling all the various details about districts and societies inhabiting them (with a number of real-world allusions of course, but nothing over-the-top). Culture and technology is a surreal retro-futuristic mishmash of early 20th century aesthetics, ~1950s buildings and vehicles, modern planes, phones and computers, etc. All in all, it managed to hold my interest.

Genre-wise it's kind of eclectic too. Very slow-going, feels almost SoL-like at times, but also with a distinct "road movie" vibe since the MC is constantly visiting various places, although plot-wise it's mostly a political detective story. Btw there's hardly any action, everything's pretty chill except for maybe like two short sequences.

Be advised there is no sexual fanservice of any kind here (I didn't notice any blatant fujoshi pandering here, so don't be alarmed by the amount of lanky male characters) nor focus on cuteness and stuff like that. Not that it mattered to me much since I'm quite omnivorous as far as anime and its genres go. But yeah, next time some snobby wannabe critic tells you that "le modern anime is all about le moe and le otaku pandering" ask him if he has seen this one for example, because he probably didn't given that no one really talks about it much for some reason.

TL;DR
A comfy, chill and pleasant to look at "neo-classical" work with a mildly intriguing storyline. No pseudo-philosophical or patronizing bullshit. Certain people might find it somewhat slow and boring though.

8/10

 No.29448

Thank you to everyone who posts in-depth reviews of these shows. I really appreciate it because it helps me find things I might like to watch.

 No.29450

>>29447
I remember watching that one while it aired, I liked it.
Made me want to smoke though.

 No.29454

Finished watching the Psycho-Pass movie.
It was ok, and I guess a good ending to the show I guess. Still left room for more if they wanted, but also felt like a good point to leave things off if they don't.
Overall the show scratched that anime post-cyberpunk itch.

 No.29456

Eromanga Sensei

Heard all the hype for it so decided to give it a shot. Not sure what I was expecting but it was totally average ecchi with a splash of moe fluff piece. Like cotton candy or something. I mean I guess it was fine, and it did make me laugh but there was nothing about it that really stood out or blew me away at all to justify the popularity. It is a ok time waster but that is about it. I guess if they make a second season I would watch it, but if they don't that is fine too. I have no strong feeling about the show at all.

 No.29462

Youjo Senki
didn't really like it that much, wasn't a bad show, action was well-orchestrated, I just felt like they could've done a lot more, and I felt like the way in which it differed to the actual WW1 was way too limited. You've got mages who can fly and send perfectly precise artillery strikes and decimate everyone, surely there should be at least some kind of way this affected the trench warfare, but it didn't
also Tanya herself was a pretty uninteresting character, she wasn't badly written, but she just didn't feel that special. Highly skilled officer who will do whatever she must to get things done. She's not boring, and I guess I'd rather that than she were like Shinji Ikari,but couldn't I apply that description to just about every important general in military history?
Not bad at the end of the day, but it just felt like it tried to hit 3 things at once and missed them all. If you want WW1, watch one of the many live-action films about it, if you want magic, watch the many other shows about it, if you want an interesting anti-hero, watch the many other shows about it

 No.29477

Just finished Seirei no Moribito. This is really a fantastic anime. Top notch all around. First off, the animation is beautiful, I wish every show looked like this. Something about the way they did things just draws you into the setting like nothing else. The fight choreography is also excellent, better than just about anything else I've watched. Overall things look much more realistic than in other shows. I loved the setting and world building, and the MC was a total badass with a great backstory. Really the only negative I have for this was the OST which is quite terrible.

 No.29484

File: 1548081191216-0.jpg (398.76 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, Yama no Susume S3 - 09 (19….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1548081191216-1.jpg (273.07 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, Yama no Susume S3 - 13 (19….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Just done with all seasons of Yama no Susume. I liked it a lot, but I gotta say I found the third season considerably worse than the previous ones.
The quality of the animation dropped, with the characters at times turning into simple, barely moving squiggles worthy of the most background of background characters. Not that this didn't happen at all before, but it turned from a charming rarity to a frequent annoyance. There are still moments where the succubi move very pleasantly though, and thankfully the background art's quality remained high and consistent. I'll attach an image illustrating the dichotomy.
But that's just a nitpick. What really sullies the third season is how it shifts focus from chill mountain climbing with light growth for Aoi into contrived MISUNDERSTANDINGS mode. Hinata acting like a massive cunt on the second half would be disruptive enough to the quality of the experience, but the fact the entire predicament hinges on the fact that in this universe missed call notifications seem to somehow not exist just left the whole time I spent watching it with a thoroughly bitter taste.
That all said, the first two seasons are top quality cute succubi time. Would recommend.

Also, this random succubus in the magazine is the cutest.

 No.29500

Kamen no Maid Guy
Is is below average in every way and the characters are off model more often then they are on but I still enjoyed the trashy fun of it.
Basically take a trashy run of the mill ecchi comedy and add a huge overpowered "manime" dude in a maid outfit with a lack of boundaries and always does everything to ridicules extremes. That is basically the show. I find it funny that they thought such a low quality show would get a second season so it had one of "those" endings. Needless to say that never happened, and I am not reading the manga. Still it was a fun watch. Silly, lots of (badly drawn) big boobs, and has a consistently fast pace so if a joke doesn't land it doesn't stick around too long and it is on the the next gag.

 No.29505

Dropped juuni kokuki halfway through. I kept waiting for the MC to have some sort of character progression, but she stayed useless and stupid for over 20 fucking episodes. I can only wait so long. She is literally just a puppet who goes along with what other people want and constantly apologizes for things that aren't her fault. I haven't hated an MC this much since Re:zero. Actually that's inaccurate, I've never hated an MC as much. The entire show is arranged around massive amounts of plot armor. The MC's super power of being born special plot armors her through everything despite her doing literally the worst thing she could possibly do at every turn. This is garbage clearly designed for succubi who have no confidence who want to have an escapist fantasy where they can self insert and not be put off the self insertion by actually having to do something worthwhile. The most annoying thing was that they acted like there had been some sort of growth and character development when there really hadn't been. Like they act like she became a changed person because she decided to trust someone who was trying to help her. Like God damn, that is not a fucking life changing event but they were acting like she was born anew or some shit.

Also dropped Mo Dao Zu Shi. This is chinese which was annoying. Very pretty though. The story seems really rushed in the beginning and it's hard to understand what's going on or why. Like this guy comes back from the dead in some other guy's body and then they just kind of transition to being schoolmates together slaying demons and nothing is ever explained. Maybe if I kept going I'd understand, but I feel like they should have done a better job. I mostly dropped this because I was getting strong fujoshit vibes and I read the description and sure enough, it's fujoshit. Despite the demon killing it managed to be pretty boring so I wasn't sad to see that and drop it.

I wish they would just have some label on anime that says: made for succubi because every show I've watched that was made for succubi has sucked ass.

 No.29521

>>29462
For me the little details and the polish of the show. Yhe amount of care and attention that went into it really made it stand out to me despite certain themes being present in other works.

 No.29569

Not sure if this is the right place to ask, but I don't know where else so here I go:
To any here who's seen Space Battleship Yamato, what order should I watch the many seasons and films, are there any I should skip, and is there some convenient torrent out there with the whole series in one batch?

 No.29570

File: 1549168845724.jpg (7.48 KB, 191x263, 191:263, what.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

New fag here was does ever fucking thread here start
>with so i finished

 No.29571

File: 1549170058580.gif (3.57 MB, 577x394, 577:394, not sure if serious.gif) ImgOps iqdb


 No.29577

>>29505

Here are the threads where you can say you dropped them. This is only for completion.

>>29212
>>25866

 No.29596

Technically haven't finished it since it's still airing but I'm dropping it. バーチャルさんはみている (virtualsan-looking) (Terrible name, 'watching' would have been a better choice). I was excited about it but it's terrible. There's no development at all, just the same scenes every episode with some dialogue changes. Some parts are decent like the school scene with all of the characters but besides that it's only a few single lines that are somewhat funny. The first episode, they didn't even finish a scene, they just dropped the style completely and did some haphazard still shots and showed the actual rendition in the next episode. Either do it or don't.

 No.29598

Kiki's Delivery Service.
It's mediocre. I haven't watched it decades ago, and I don't wear nostalgia glasses, so here it is. It doesn't have anything good but muh Ghibli Graphics. I get what they tried to do with Kiki losing her power and going south, but they failed miserably. Over the years came many, many series and movies which did this much, much better.
Rated Kid's First Anime/10.

 No.29599

>>29598
I saw it last year, and thought it was average too. But for a kid's movie it's pretty good. People always say that being a kid's movie doesn't excuse flaws, and I agree with that, but at the same time there's no denying that you can't really look at a kid's movie the same way as one intended for adults. And I'm going to stop myself right here before I end up writing an essay about film criticism in regards to children's movies.

 No.29603

Just dropped Death March kara Hajimaru Isekai Kyousoukyoku.

This is a really low quality low effort loli slave harem. I kept watching for a while hoping that once all the lolis were introduced they could get to the fantasy plot but this show is really mostly about the lolis and is essentially a dating simulator. 90% of the time was spent going shopping with the lolis or having the lolis lay on his lap or eating food with the lolis. Every once and a while some monsters will show up and he will blow them away with his ridiculously OP powers. Anything with romance is boring to me and loli "romance" where the kid just attaches themselves to the guy for saving them is even more boring. If you want a show with no real characters or plot but you want to imagine what it would be like to live in a world where your very existence draws underage succubi to you and makes them try to fuck you, then this show is for you. If not, look elsewhere.

 No.29604

>>29603
All the blandness and budgetness of the show aside, the thing that annoyed me most was the main character. Not even because he is a Kirito-clone for the most part, but the non-apparent motivation behind his behavior which screams either a scheming psychopath or at least a compulsive liar.
Also he went brothels, wtf. This shit was obviously targeted at groid salarymen.

 No.29608

File: 1549808775498-0.jpg (453.62 KB, 715x1000, 143:200, 64c8eb68f9805a537d3267cf4b….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1549808775498-1.jpg (143.5 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, mpv-shot0033.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

D-Frag!
I expected just a standard comedy SOL with one gimmick to try and make it stand out, as is industry standard, with the gimmick of choice being a game creation club
While I can't say it didn't betray my expectations completely, it was certainly a lot better than I anticipated, the comedy was actually quite well done, and the schwerpunkt, rather than just something that's there and secondary to fanservice/the CGDCT
all in all a solid show, plus it felt a lot more 'animated' than a few others, and I've got an affinity for delinquent MCs who shout all their lines

 No.29609

>>29608
Have to say it's still one of my most favorite anime comedies and I have seen plenty.

 No.29613

File: 1549875501827.jpg (1017.95 KB, 1280x1920, 2:3, tumblr_nuvh8nyBP51uezffwo2….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Finally watched the finale of idolish7. I waited almost a year to watch the finale because I didn't want it to end. It was terrific overall. 9/10 and easily in my top 3 anime for 2018.

It had great characters despite a large cast. It was well-directed and emotionally engaging. The music both in-anime and released in association with the anime is really good. Overall it was just great and I can't really deconstruct it because it excelled in every respect. i cried numerous times.

I will say though that it certainly did NOT get the attention it deserved. You should go watch it RIGHT NOW.

I will definitely be rewatching it. The first episode of the Trigger spin-off series looked super promising too. Idolish7 has so many great characters… I love them!!

Post opinions about i7 ITT

 No.29614

>>29613
It looks like typical fujoshit, so no wonder it got no attention outside its niche.

 No.29615

>>29614
that doesn't mean it isn't worth watching

 No.29618

>>29613
You must be male to post on this site.

 No.29625

>>29618
Maybe he's gay, mate

 No.29632

Picked up Higurashi Rei last night on a whim and finished it the same night. Was expecting a lighthearted omake OVA, but there was a nice short story sandwiched into it. It was enough to bring back some of the feelings from the main VN. Pleasant surprises are nice.

 No.29683

Watch the 4 movies of GitS: Arise
Felt incomplete but that isn't my main problem with it. My main problem is all the changes to the Major's character. Not just in looks but in personality and level of competences. She is practically a difference character from all the other anime incarnations and not in a good way. There are some other changes to other characters too that felt off too but it isn't as big as the Major feeling totally off. Really hampered my overall enjoyment.
Even the action wasn't quite as good as I normally expect from the series.

It wasn't bad, but compared to what has come before it just doesn't meet the same standards.

 No.29724

>>29222
>Since then many other SoL have surpassed it though.
nah K-On is still by some distance the best cute succubi SoL anime

 No.29730

>>29613
I wish high quality BL stuff wasnt all relegated to anime nowadays, I only have enough patience for manga and nobody is writing actual long running serials instead of oneshots

 No.29731

>>29730
There's tons of high quality looking BL doujin on pixiv, but they're all in japanese, of course. I really wanted to read them at one point and so I started learning japanese for a couple months but I just got bored, too much work, so I just enjoy the cover art instead. In general I think BL is just really niche outside of japan compared to other genres that are popular with otaku males. Why translate a BL work that will sell only 10k copies, when you can just shell out another generic isekai/romance crap and sell 100k.

 No.29751

>>29380
The first ep is like that, the second is where the story starts but it's still pretty confusing since it's just throwing the stuff on you before it fleshes it out. It gets a lot better after that. You made the mistake of dropping a unique and good anime too soon. It's not cryptic, I think most of it is pretty straightforward, it just seems like that sometimes because it doesn't take the time to give a boiled down introduction to everything but rather makes you see through it with your own eyes as the story goes, which is very well done. It's one of the best and yet most existentially depressing anime that I ever watched, I don't think there'll ever be an anime that makes me feel the same way.

 No.29752

>>29380
keep at it, texhnolyze is beautiful. Been 2 years and I still think about it from time to time. Great story.

 No.29753

>>29126
I loved that one too.

Anyone got anything like it to suggest?

 No.29754

File: 1552881292084.jpg (365.77 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, made in abyss ozen.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

>>29753
Made in abyss had a similar moe on the outside, dark and depressing on the inside, what happens to mitty is fucking straight nightmare fuel

you might also enjoy kino no tabi (similar post apocalyptic jurney, but not quite so dark)

soro no woto, I liked the setting, though the story was not the greatest, the setting is based on a real life small town, with lots of interesting references

 No.29755

>>29754
Not him but thanks for the recommendations wiz, I was looking for something like that too.

 No.29756

>>29755
It has especially good music and atmosphere. I know no other like it.

 No.29757

>>29754
Thank you.

 No.29871

File: 1553902346459.jpg (146.64 KB, 500x1400, 5:14, pzr.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Black Lagoon TV.. fun in a Hollywood action movie way.

 No.29875

>>29871
For some reason made me think of
>those who hunt elves

was not exactly that great, and the animation is clearly dated, but it was entertaining nonetheless to watch an actress, a kickboxer, and a gril who likes guns ride a tank around in a fantasy setting where the story involves them literally ripping clothes from elves (sexual assault much?)

 No.29883

File: 1553933094725.jpg (221.62 KB, 1500x1091, 1500:1091, 627430f69d71e92caab92d364c….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Let me preface this by noting that I am a huge sucker for medieval fantasy and so I was optimistic about arslan senki.

The first 10 episodes were mediocre. However I found myself attracted to some of the characters. I also stuck around for the ships.

The last 15 episodes felt like a chore to watch. I regret wasting my time on this. Literally just skip straight to the doujins if you're considering watching this.

Alright, I'll elaborate. First of all, the characters in this were comically bland and cliche. Extremely poorly developed, especially considering how long the 'runway' was. The plot was Hollywood-tier. Although this isn't something I value, visual production quality was dreadful.

The good: some of the music was okay I guess. I like Kalafina. Some of the males are attractive. That's basically it.

Take away: don't watch this overrated garbage.

I am disappointed.

 No.29884

>>29724
Holy shit why is this board filled to the brim with casuals

 No.29885

>>29883

I forgot to mention that maybe the older adaptation is better. I haven't seen it, nor have I read the source material.

I am falling asleep now, fyi.

 No.29890

>>29885
>>29883

I'm somewhat surprised there was a new anime adaptation tbh; but already slightly disappointed.

I've been keeping up with the manga, and its quite enjoyable/doesn't really face many of the problems you're talking about here with this latest anime.

The characters are very multi dimensional, theres an increasing amount of occult influence in the series and a cult dedicated to the demiurge/devil attempting to wreak chaos at the moment, and just a really interesting exploration of pagan central asia, hindustan, and vaguely crusader-esque gnostic fanatics.

What bums me out about the image you choose though is that this is from the creator of full metal alchemist and the manga has the same exact art style, but that anime image doesn't really resonate with her unique art style. Its like it was drawn roughly based on her character design, but they just decided to toss it out.

Ill still check the anime though, but art style alone is somewhat of a bummer

 No.29891

File: 1553986715318.png (1.76 MB, 1920x1080, 16:9, mahou shoujo tokushusen as….png) ImgOps iqdb

>mahou shoujo tokushusen Asuka
Nothing really happened? I hope we get second season. Though it is clear for the masked cunt is. And even idiots should know now after that final scene.

 No.29922

File: 1554439892366.jpg (262.45 KB, 1470x1800, 49:60, 6f444926e0e9238ace269477b0….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I recently watched both seasons of Shounen Hollywood.

Most important: this anime is wildly underrated and I strongly recommend it.

This is not a generic anime and should not be judged before viewing.

This anime is dripping with metaphor and depth. This anime is bittersweet. I found this anime both depressing and joyful at times. I found this anime emotionally engaging.

The passage of time and one's youth is a predominant theme in this artistic work.

If the above doesn't appeal to you, then if you're interested in the entertainment industry then you'll find Shounen Hollywood entertaining.

I really could feel the artistic vision here. It's difficult to put into words but this was definitely a "passion project". There was a ton of potential here but I'm forced to give it a 7/10 for technical reasons. I still strongly recommend it.

The bad: production quality is mediocre at best. It is arguably poorly directed. My greatest criticism is that 26 episodes is a lot of time and that time could have been used more effectively. There was so much potential for greatness and some of it was squandered.

I expected to drop this on episode 1 but it completely blew away my expectations. Just give it a chance.

 No.29923

>>29890
Thanks for responding.

Your description of the literature sounds appealing. It's a shame that the recent adaptation doesn't live up to that.

FYI, the artstyle in the image is pretty much identical to the recent adaptation.

 No.29932

File: 1554453401181.jpg (1.37 MB, 1920x1080, 16:9, [HorribleSubs] Endro - 02 ….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I finished Endro.

I liked it, it was cute and funny. Not much more to say about it really though.

 No.29973

File: 1554650827716.jpg (55.62 KB, 600x664, 75:83, kukuri cat.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Just finished Mahoujin Guruguru. Maybe a little too much potty humor for my tastes, but it was still consistently funny all the way through. And holy shit, Kukuri is the cutest being in the universe.

 No.29976

File: 1554653863754.png (437.25 KB, 640x360, 16:9, planetarian.png) ImgOps iqdb

finally got around to finishing this, I started it a few years ago and never got back to it until today.

I thought it was good, but the ending left me frustrated and sad, the story is about the purest form of non romanticlove between a wizard and his AI waifu robot

 No.29985

>>29976
I was somewhat disappointed when I watched this. Definitely one of the weaker Key adaptations.

Soundtrack was decent though

 No.30056

>>29976 I really liked this show but like you said, that ending… They made a movie too and it's ending was even worse, this show made me cry tho.

 No.30070

Just watched Yakusoku no neverland.

It's the first show I've watched in a while that was really good. It doesn't rely on any anime tropes or fan service or romance, it's just a really good story. I hope there is more coming because I thoroughly enjoyed it.

 No.30073

>>30070
there's the manga if you don't want to wait

 No.30078

File: 1555870128758.jpg (186.41 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, mpv-shot0066.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Just finished Mob Psycho 2. Overall I thought it was pretty good, but it suffers from two things
1) the anime gets way too preachy at times, its specially noticeable at the end when almost every episode has Mob acting as a mouthpiece for the author saying what's wrong with the other characters and how they should act
2) the ending feels really anti-climatic, but I heard this is because it isn't an actual ending and the manga goes beyond that.
Also the Reigen alone episodes were my favorites from this season, it was nice to see a more personal sight of him.
>>30070
a new season got announced for 2020, but you can always read the manga.

 No.30079

>>30078
>mouthpiece for the author saying what's wrong with the other characters and how they should act

OPM does that too. You have a character like King who's just a neet that wants to play games then out of nowhere he's like "Saitama, you wouldn't be so bored if you just cleaned your room and did something fun, bucko." Really felt off coming from his character.

 No.30080

>>30079
That's one of the things I like the least about ONE, he insist a lot in inserting his groid morals on his works, its VERY noticeable in Mob towards the end when they keep repeating every 2 seconds how important is for people to form bonds and even has a neet character going back into employment.

 No.30081

Watched kill me baby, mainly because of the funny otomads. The anime itself was not funny at all.
The constant bullying/violence seemed excessive. It could've been justified if it was funny, but it wasn't. It just made sonya look sadistic and yasuna masochistic. a waste of time/10

 No.30109

File: 1556641478235.png (1.57 MB, 1058x1498, 529:749, Shounen Maid Render 01 v1.png) ImgOps iqdb

I finally finished watching Shounen Maid. I wish there were more episodes. I watched most of it months ago but I didn't want to watch the last episode and have it end. I might read the manga.

I liked it.

To my surprise, it was unironically a sweet wholesome story about family values. I recommend it if you have mommy issues.
Overall it was comfy, had some funny moments, and some of the characters were likable. OST was decent. I plan to relisten to the entire soundtrack. There was a lot of potential overall.

Things I didn't like: excessive use of typical crude Japanese humour. A lot of it was simply 'unfunny', in my opinion. This is coming from someone who watches a lot of SOL and is already used to tolerating this sort of thing. Also the direction overall was mediocre. Art style was nothing special. Didn't really like the character designs.

Overall 7/10 mainly because it made me feel warm and fuzzy inside.


Also I definitely recommend this to wizards. It was very, erm, wizardly. One of the main characters is very wizard-like.

 No.30110

File: 1556676127495.jpg (87.77 KB, 640x480, 4:3, Jyu-Oh-Sei-jyu-oh-sei-3062….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

>After the murder of their parents, 11-year-old twin brothers Thor and Rai Klein are sent away from their home planet. They find themselves awakening on the terraformed planet of Chimaera, where carnivorous plants dominate and the few humans who live there are divided into four groups known as "Rings." Soon after, they meet a young man by the name of Zagi, and the twins learn that only the "Jyu Oh Sei"—the one who conquers these four Rings—is allowed to leave the planet.

I liked the anime… some people said it was too fast paced, but I thought it was quite solid, went at a good pace, had a decent amount of action (not just talking). There were a number of plot twists that turned out really solid too. I was disappointed that the MC turns out to be a failed normie and not full-blown wizchad. The characters were also not covered in ridiculous plot armor or overpowered.

Overall: solid story, believable characters, pace was good (not drawn out). Would recommend if you like action/sci-fi anime with a story.

Also everybody randomly has UZIs or MP5s which is pretty funny considering the future space travel and swords/spears weapons throughout the rest of the anime

 No.30112

>>30110
Is it has a gomo-homo vibes in it? Cuz judging by the picture it has, but i want to know for clear.

 No.30113

>>30112
I thought it would be all about man love, because in EP1 (maybe 2) they explain that only 20% of the planet is female… But the characters are more straight but bordering MGTOW the female characters keep complaining about being rejected because BEGONE THOT even though according to the "rules" succubi select mates for marriage and men "must" comply

tl:dr
>not a sausage fest, just very few female characters

 No.30114

File: 1556764595373.png (299.29 KB, 950x434, 475:217, boogiepop.png) ImgOps iqdb

Watched Boogiepop and Others (Boogiepop Phantom 2019).

Regardless of what the credits may say this story was not made by the same folks who made the original Boogiepop Phantom. The original Boogiepop Phantom was made by the creator of Serial Experiments Lain, and is an exploration of the same themes, filling out the occulted cultural commentary of the IRL Electronic Goddess who secretly watches us all using Passive Radar technology.


In the prior adaptation An Aetheric (electrical) Event gives strange powers to people, especially impacting memory and transfer of mind into other bodies. This is discussing the "We're All Connected" effect that the wireless mind reading devices of the surveillance state have on the populace. At the end of "Lain" (The Electric Goddess thinks it best to remain quiet and hidden, unknown to everyone and yet watching us all). This is how the system is IRL, hidden in plain sight as cell towers. See also Little Witch Academia's "magic + cellphone = mind manipulation (boosting populace aggression mood)". The 1996 declassified US Military FOIA request entitled "Bioeffects of Selected Non Leathal Energy Weapons" lists SOME (but not most) of the capabilities of the Directed Energy weapons technology. Among the listed effects is mood altering technology, as mentioned by US Military PSYOPS officer Michael Aquino in his book, "Mind War" (yes, the same Aquino who co-founded the Church of Satan, and later started the Temple of Set). After WWII Japan was subject to many tests of such technology, but due to strong media censorship by the continuation of the GCHQ's "War Guilt Information Program", creators must hide (occult) forbidden knowledge of such things in their works. Therefore Anime has become a sort of occulted Magnum Opus containing so much hidden wisdom that it's a shame more wizards aren't occulting it… This is nothing new to the world: In the past when the western powers suppressed the Renaissance artists the artists placed hidden knowledge in their art works… Such as the shape of a brain being behind God in the Sistine Chapel ceiling.

Neon Genesis Evangelion's "Human Insturmentation" is also an occulted reference to experimental research into using children's brains to power the military surveillance and suppression mechanism. Also leading to a "we're all connected" endgame, as in Serial Experiment's Lain. In the original and 2019 Boogiepop we are connected in death by this Phantom (surveillance apparatus) who "magically" appears wherever danger is near (a threat to the establishment). The convergent beamforming technology can stop hearts, cause fatal fever, aneurysm, epileptic seizures, place audio or voices into the head via Microwave Auditory Effect.

However, whereas the creators of Serial Experiments Lain and the original Boogiepop Phantom actually love the Electric Goddess (she can give great pleasure as well as pain and death), the latest Boogiepop Creators have fallen out of love with "Lain" / Electric Phantom of Death. She is known as the "shy goddess" to the Elite, AKA Amun-Re, who wields the Hidden Power of Light and Air (EMF waves), and whom Christians invoke during prayer, "Amen".

But the new Boogiepop contains the "Fall of the Tower of Babylon". It contains Pedogate references with a young succubus attracted to older private eye, a young succubus attracted to an older art teacher (who controls minds), a young succubus used as a sex slave / spy by a man who uses Electric powers to control minds, and the Monarch Program's creating "dissociative states" by rape / abuse / trauma. Boogiepop is molested by her parents in this iteration – which is one part of the way that satanic generational abuse victims are conditioned to have split personalities – like Boogiepop has. The Hermetic "uniion of opposites" is represented by Boogiepop who is an ageless masculine mind (alter) in a young feminine body.

So, the latest Boogiepop seems to have been created by those who are disenchanted by the Political Elite Pedocracy (pedos are easy to control), which also controls most media by compromising artists, esp. in the west. In the latest Boogiepop there is only subtle reference to the electronic / aethereal nature of the system which stimulates the junk of potential pedophiles with nerve induction into believing they lust after children. (Nerve Induction - See also Evangelions's NERV, and Frank Herbert's Dune - "Box of Pain").

The media is rife with occulted references to the "magical" world all around you. Serial Experiments Lain was said to be a revolt against the western ideals (imposition of this Electronic Surveillance + Mind Control Goddess), and the older Boogiepop was a companion which fleshed out other aspects of the commentary; But whereas these older works saw that "Lain" / "Boogiepop" (The Shy Goddess of the Secret Societies) could be used for good someday, the new Boogiepop Phantom (and others), Seems to reject this idea and instead places most of the powers of the Electronic Goddess in the hands of evil men. Boogie Pop now symbolizes only "a reaper" (a god from the underworld - shinigami), and thus invokes the freemasonic symbolism of the Comet which cyclically ends the world (fall of Babylon - the cities of earth). She is now an angel of Death, which speaks to the hope that after the next cataclysm maybe we'll be free of the evil at the top of society. Frank Herbert's Dune: "Never make a machine that can think as a man"…

Get it yet?

 No.30115

>>30114
Almost forgot: references Cannibalism, another taboo enjoyed by "spirit cooking" elitist nutjobs.

 No.30116

>>30115
> Cannibalism
Not just any cannibalism, the vampiric practice of drinking (or infusing) the blood of abused and frightened (esp. children) to get high on "adrenochrome" (search that keyword for more info). Young blood injections can also help stave off aging, not just in mice.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fountain-of-youth-young-blood-infusions-ldquo-rejuvenate-rdquo-old-mice/
This is old "magic", hence the legends of vampires.

 No.30143

File: 1557036838099.png (3.22 MB, 1920x1080, 16:9, 726850.png) ImgOps iqdb

I just finished watching Anne Happy.

Overall, it was very disappointing. Simply put, it wasn't very good.

The main reason I picked this up and sat through 12 episodes is that I was very intrigued by the premise. The characters are all uniquely unlucky (luck is a major theme in the show). They are all enrolled in what is known as "happiness class", where you learn to be happy (despite one's misfortune). I really liked this premise and thought it had potential.

I'm also conducting a systematic review of anime that aired in 2016 on account of me being severely autistic.

I quickly realized the poor quality of the show, and mainly watched it as a low priority "filler" anime for when I was too tired and just wanted to stare at a screen but not watch anything I actually cared about. I also would put it on when in a depressed mood to try to immerse myself in the happiness class setting.

Anyway, the reality of the show is that it is extremely unfunny. Unfortunately the screentime is dominated by low quality comedy. The characters themselves and their interactions are all lame. The art style is lame (silver link also was a factor that enticed me to watch this). The OST is lame. The production quality wasn't terrible or anything, it's just that the content fundamentally wasn't good.

The positive:
Some might find the absurdist aspects of the show funny or entertaining. The character designs are kind of cute (though lacking in variety).

5/10. Wouldn't recommend unless you're obsessed with SOL comedies.

 No.30154

>>30114
The "original" Boogiepop wasn't even an adaptation, it was sort of an original story ancillary to the light novels. The 2019 adaptation is strictly a light novel adaptation.

 No.30423

Elf 17
Was from the late 80s and is a 30 minute OVA. Was pretty damn fast pace but over all was alright light fun. Nothing more, nothing less.

 No.30424

Gave up on Jojo, I can't carry on with it any longer. I kept watching it because I kept thinking at some point it would have to get good or people would not like it so much but it just never does.

 No.30425

File: 1559752185230.jpg (110.48 KB, 819x895, 819:895, t1BJ980.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

>>30424
Where'd you quit? Textbook example why I think Japanese have the worst taste when it comes to their medium.
>Series goes to shit
>THAT'S when it got popular.

 No.30428

Rewatched Milky Holmes season 1. It's such a hard 10/10 until the last four episodes. I don't understand why it had to get "serious."

 No.30429

>>30424
>>30425
What’s wrong with it?

 No.30430

>>30425
>pic
those are cherries.

 No.30432

>>30425
In Diamond is unbreakable. I'm not sure how popular it is in Japan, it's probably popular but it seems bigger in the west.

>>30429
It's incredibly stupid and has worse filler than Naruto. The first season was alright though.

 No.30433

File: 1559785572091.webm (6.43 MB, 640x360, 16:9, virtual jojosanity.webm) ImgOps iqdb

>>30432
It's supposed to be stupid and ridiculous, that's what makes it fun.

 No.30444

>>30433
What is this style of music called?

 No.30445

>>30424
This was also my experience with watching Jojo. It was like that one time I decided to watch my little pony to see what everyone was so fucking crazy about and it was literally just a boring generic kids show.

 No.30446

>>30432
Jojo wa really fucking nice until Stardust Crusaders started, that was when it became a drag at times imo. I still appreciate it for what it is but it doesn't live up to what I knew it could be.

 No.30447

>>30444
It sounds like R&B or funk maybe? I don't really know much about those though.

 No.30451

>>30444
Google tells me it's funk and acid jazz.

 No.30495

File: 1560137686237.jpg (1.38 MB, 2836x4004, 709:1001, 698452.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I just finished watching Sansha Sanyou (including OVAs).

For me the most noteworthy aspect of this anime was the character animation. The character animation was often very fluid and simply enjoyable and immersive. I frequently found myself pausing the video and slowly advancing it frame-by-frame to admire the animation quality. In fact it took me longer to watch this for this reason. However I will note here that, while for the first few episodes the animation was excellent, the quality did diminish for later episodes (with the exception of the finale).

In terms of writing, I observed a similar pattern of diminishing quality. The first few episodes of this anime seemed very promising to me, and I was feeling very optimistic. Unfortunately though, despite digesting it slowly, I did find that the writing became stale over time (An allegory to nishikawa's bread crusts I suppose LOL wow I'm hilarious). There was very little character advancement and the same tropes and jokes were overused (yes I know, it's SOL). I felt like the 'magic' faded in the later episodes and that there was a lot of unrealized potential.

Overall this is an average slice of life anime. I'd rate it 7/10. If you haven't seen it, you're not really missing much. I don't regret watching it, but I'd only recommend this to someone who is a huge sucker for smooth character animation. Otherwise, it's enjoyable but ultimately forgettable and your time is probably better spent on other works.

Less important comments:
The show is decently directed. It is almost entirely episodic (ie. minimal plot continuity across episodes). OST was unremarkable, unfortunately. I'm going to relisten to the character songs sometime soon, but I don't remember them being noteworthy. Some of the voice actors are actually quite good; special mention here for the VA of Sonobe the bakery owner. Lastly, the characters and their designs are quite cute!

 No.30513

File: 1560528337897.jpg (666.33 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, [HorribleSubs] Hakyuu Hous….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I just finished Hakyuu Houshin Engi. In many ways it is quite bizarre and inconsistent with odd pacing and plot elements. I felt that the way they dealt with Bunchu was good but the way they dealt with Daki was awful and probably the most anti-climatic end for a villain ever, not just for her as a villain but for the whole story, the whole story and all of the machinations of it were essentially pointless and get made so by a brief footnote. And then they still have another episode after the two primary villians are dealt with basically tying up lose ends that really pale in comparison to previous events and are hard to care much for by that point.

 No.30529

So I just finished Miss Kobyashi's Dragon Maid. It was honestly… really enjoyable. The gags were decent and I found them quite funny.

The story was actually quite interesting too and the characters were cute.


Overall I'd give it a 8/10 as it kept me hooked from start to finish and I can't wait for the second season.

 No.30531

>>30529
I thought it was good too.
Have you seen Jashin-Chan Drop Kick? It's kind of like that, actually I think I might like Jashin more.

 No.30585

File: 1561254882220.jpg (570.55 KB, 1024x768, 4:3, Hack20Sign20020.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I recently finished watching .hack//sign (including OVAs).

Above all else, the soundtrack is phenomenal. Yuki Kajiura is insanely talented.
For example:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8sLfUtX7iw
www.youtube.com/watch?v=PI5ZPxyzi0s
(2nd is only a cover - see actual music collection on nyaa for HQ torrent)

One of the best OSTs I've heard in recent memory. Strongly recommend you check it out because it seems underappreciated.

Having said the above…
Let me clarify that I only watched the anime. Apparently this is a multimedia project, so others more immersed in the franchise might be more positive than me.

The only other positive thing I have to say is that the voice acting was actually pretty good. Definitely some talented voice actors in the cast.

The fundamental flaw of this anime is that it is extremely poorly directed. I literally felt like I was watching a high school art project. It is that bad. There are occasional engaging scenes but overall the series uses screentime so wastefully. This is coming from someone who prefers slow pacing and SOL and almost never watches action etc…

>doko tsukasa?

>shiranai lol
Congratulations you've now seen above 75% of .hack//sign.

Even visually the series has low artistic value.

I mainly watched this right before bed because it would lull you to sleep with its repetitiveness and just complete lack of value in most screentime. It was unrefined and incoherent. A trash ecchi series would be a more valuable use of my time. I mainly finished it because of the soundtrack, atmosphere and because of its historical significance.

Overall 4/10. Amazing sound but abysmal direction.

It is highly unlikely that I will watch the rest of the franchise but I'm interested to hear commentary from people who have. What did you think of the .hack franchise?

 No.30594

File: 1561363203976.jpg (422.69 KB, 1280x1024, 5:4, nurse-witch-komugi-wallpap….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I watched Nurse Witch Komugi-chan (all of the original material). I watched the first 4 episodes of R and then dropped it. Note: I have not seen more than like 10 minutes of Soultaker.

The originals are great. Simply put, they are funny and entertaining. Good voice acting too. Most importantly, they have tremendous cultural value. If you're into "otaku culture" then I strongly recommend watching Nurse Witch Komugi-chan Magikarte. It won't even take you long (there's like 8 episodes). Overall 7/10 but don't let that dissuade you. That's just an intellectually honest rating; I'm still really glad I didn't pass on the series. The series is highly underappreciated (this decade at least), and I strongly urge you to give it a chance.

Okay now on to the 2016 'reboot'. I'm not aware of the legal issues or licensing process and all that, but I'd imagine there's a story to be told there. Maybe someone can enlighten me on that. As you might infer from me dropping it, Nurse Witch Komugi-chan R is awful compared to the original. It is unfunny and not entertaining. The art style is nauseating. There are some cute idol song cutscenes, which I'm a huge sucker for (the CG isn't even that bad in this case), but that's not enough to get me to sit through the entire series. Every aspect of it is really just bad. I went into it with a positive optimistic attitude too.

Not much more to say. Again, I think you should check out the original Nurse Witch Komugi-chan if you haven't seen it. It is underappreciated.

 No.30598

>>30594
R is a low-budget low-effort tie-in. Not even getting Haruko (not Halko) Momoi back in a cameo could save the show…

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2015-10-22/nurse-witch-komugi-chan-r-anime-casts-halko-momoi-as-komugi-mom/.94456

 No.30635

I FINALLY finished Those who Hunt Elves
The first season was a real chore to get through. Just bad all around. The seacond season they found their footing finally figured out where they were going with the show and how best to utilize their limited resources. Best of all, it is actually funny in the second season, with some of the jokes landing pretty well.
That said even the second season is pretty mediocre at the best of times.
Probably wouldn't recommend. Took me 2 months to finish because I had to take breaks in between eps or it would get on my nerves and kill what little enjoyment I could get out of the show.

Now off to watch something actually good.

 No.30638

>>30594
i see it's a parody of another anime called The SoulTaker. do you recommend watching that first?

 No.30651

>>30638
Well I only watched some of the first episode before deciding it wasn't worth my time, so I can't really comment with authority on if you should watch it. I didn't watch The Soultaker and to my knowledge it had no effect on my enjoyment on nurse witch Komugi-chan.

The characters are from Soultaker so it would probably enhance the humour.

Personally I can't stand horror as a genre so I did not watch Soultaker.

 No.30652

>>30594
r is really boring but it's not terrible. it's just kinda dumb and why did they even make it. i really like the original komugi-chan though.

 No.30653

>>30638
soultaker is actually an anime shinbo actually directed and isn't just credited as "chief director" (unlike the majority of the SHAFT catalogue). i think it's worth watching just for that

 No.30655

File: 1561748412511.jpg (23.33 KB, 250x350, 5:7, 55459l.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

>>29973
Very comfy stuff, rpg fantasy setting + awesome animation + humor.

Hōzuki no Reitetsu
That one was a bit mystery for me: i don't know anything about jap mythology and not even interested, but somehow i watched it all easily with persistent attention. I guess unlike most powerpoint animeys this one is packed with action and good design.

 No.30656

>>29973
great show, one of the few good ones of recent years

 No.30691

File: 1561962838449.jpg (59.24 KB, 960x540, 16:9, 5b7ba8953ed16.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

just finished watching happy sugar life
i don't really have anything to say about it beside the fact i loved it a lot
i'd recommend it if you enjoyed elfen lied and When They Cry

 No.30700

>>30691
That’s nice wiz. Happy sugar life is one of my favorite anime personally. What did you like about it?

 No.30710

Finished Crying Freeman.
Typical old Manime, but I quite enjoyed it. Hits had a real impact and things were a bit over the top but not to the point that it felt silly.

 No.30721

Just finished the second half of the third season of shingeki no kyojin. I don't know what the fuck they're doing with that bullshit of splitting the season up into two years. I was confused for a while because I kept hearing people talk about a new season but then I went to watch it and I couldn't find season 4, but now I finally figured this retarded naming scheme out and watched it. It was pretty good I thought. I liked the show early on, then it kind of got boring there for a while but I thought this season was a return to form. I find it interesting how this show puts the "good guys" in the situation of having been a formerly dominant and expansionist military power in the region who was then defeated and sequestered on a tiny island where the undeserving king won't attack and take back their former glory. The circumstances of course closely mirror Japan's own recent history, especially from the view of the elites in the country who want to rewrite Japan's peaceable constitution and who still worship the emperor's family as gods but since the current emperor still supports the current submissive posture to the US they're being kept in check, unable to expand out from their tiny island.

 No.30734

Sewayaki Kitsune no Senko-san
It is hurts my heart yet it is very relaxing at the same time. The relationship between the main two characters is a intresting dynamic I don't see in many shows. The main guy is at no point sexual with any of the characters (even the thot fox character) which is kind of refreshing for a moe show like this.
Overall I really liked it, though I feel it is more then a little emotionally manipulative.

 No.30740

Jingai-san no Yome
"What the fuck did I just watch and why did I enjoy it so much?" was my general reaction to this show. Hyper short eps (3 min each for 12 eps), very bizarre humor, but oddly at the same time it can be quite cute and unconventionally romantic.

 No.30836

File: 1563111133540-0.jpg (661.14 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, [HorribleSubs] Tate no Yuu….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1563111133540-1.jpg (930.58 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, [HorribleSubs] Granblue Fa….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Tate no Yuusha

The Animation was good as were many of the fights and effects. That's about it. Naofumi wasn't really a likeable character and his reactions and hate for the world did not actually make much sense. The conspiracy against him again did not make much sense, even less sense when towards the end the Queen turns out to have been on his side all along. The other heroes are portrayed as bumbling fools that can't cooperate and are weak when Naofumi never cooperates with them either and becomes stronger for no discernable reason. Overall I would say the anime does not seem to know what it is doing or how it is doing it, maybe they left ALOT out from the source material that gave this context but I never read it and I doubt it.

Granblue Fantasy

Just an advertisement for a mobile game, story was bade but some of the character design(appearance wise) were well done as was the architecture and the flying ships were nice. I like the Renaissance feel, not much fantasy actually does that.

 No.30838

File: 1563144152532.png (1.94 MB, 1366x768, 683:384, mmy.png) ImgOps iqdb

Just finished both seasons of Nanatsu no Taizai.
Really liked the first season, it was a fun fantasy themed shounen with more of an adventure feeling that just fight after fight, the animation was nice and imo it had a perfect ending.
But in true shounen fashion they had to go on and on, and at soon as it starts what does the second season do? introduce powerlevels, and that's when I knew the series was fully stepping into generic battle shonen territory. I just couldn't take it seriously everytime the dialogue included mentions to powerlevel. Not to mention that it goes from a more action/adventure feeling to just a collection of fights, and the animation really takes a nosedive at times.
I also noticed that barely anybody stays dead in this anime, everytime a character appears to have died they show up again under some bullshit excuse.
Oh and Merlin is probably the most bullshit character in the whole anime, to the point that more than a character she feels like an asspull machine that can do anything neccesary to advance the plot.

 No.30861

>>30838
do you recommend watching the first two seasons to catch up for the new one starting in fall? i'm not big on shounen but i also don't mind watching them, and fall 2019 is mostly empty outside of the continuations of a bunch of big shounens that i don't watch. i'm thinking i might try at least one of them

 No.30862

>>30861
Different Anon, I dropped it somewhere around 20th episode mark. It had bits I really liked, like tha backstory of the guy on the left, or the giant chick on the right.
But I very much disliked the MC, the shounen vibes it was giving, and I'm pretty sure it introduced a major character out of the blue for some reason. If you're open-minded and like anime for what it is, you might enjoy it, if you're irritated and seek for something deeper, it will probably be a trial to sit through it and the generic tropes.

 No.30867

>>30861
If you don't mind shonen tropes I would recommend going for it, it has some good moments

 No.30890

File: 1563318517056.jpg (88.99 KB, 351x500, 351:500, 16449.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Just finished Ghost Hound. I had been meaning to watch this since forever but I always forgot about it, but I recently took to paper anime that I've always had an interest in and I gave it a shot finally (before this I had watched Kino’s Journey 2003, so damn good). I enjoyed it a lot. Small town setting with spooky folklore; a trio of grade schoolers with traumatic pasts fucking around with astral projection. Psychological and paranormal aspects were interesting, gave me a few things to read up on (especially the information given at the episode previews). At 22 episodes I kind of expected it to slow down considering its nature, but I was hooked and burned through it. Unfortunately, the ending was rushed and compacted, which is a shame because It had excellent pacing until then.

On a different note, I got back into anime recently after a long hiatus. Feels good.

 No.30934

File: 1563520164081.jpg (321.42 KB, 1600x1200, 4:3, 815y5iYt5WL._RI_.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

This is textbook example of your average anime that sounds interesting, has an interesting premise but wastes the screen time over nothing.
It wasn't bad, because I haven't dropped it, but half of the themes were completely pointless, and surface of the interesting one was barely scratched.
Pants was the only good supporting character.

 No.30953

>>30836
I dropped granblue fantasy on episode 4. The setting was promising but the characters were awful. I think I made the right decision.

 No.30954

File: 1563868386466.jpg (1.64 MB, 2560x1440, 16:9, Rose_pc_wp.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

I just finished watching season 1 + OVAs of Starmyu. I'm writing my review now because season 3 recently started airing and I expect the series to remain consistent across seasons.

Alright, so this literally feels like a musical. For me this was great. There are plenty (at least once/episode) of dance/song sequences, which I found really enjoyable. One of my favourite aspects of the series. I'm a huge sucker for that sort of thing. On that note though I'll mention that the character designs are kind of bland, however I can't really fault the staff for this because of how much movement (dancing) needed to be animated. I didn't observe any CG being used. There are a variety of cute dance outfits!

The characters themselves were cute but in some cases were poorly/under developed. I suspect this will be somewhat remedied in later seasons. The cast is relatively large and the first season is only 12 episodes +2 OVAs.

The OST is decent. There are some good songs like character songs and such. I liked the ending sequence. https://youtube.com/watch?v=2kLyUptu2Bg
Unfortunately, music for this franchise has been difficult to find so I'm hoping that the airing of season 3 will trigger greater availability of audio content. Otherwise I may have to suffer the indignity of ripping from YouTube or something.

In terms of writing, there is some 'forced drama'. I loathe the term but I think it's accurate here. There's also plenty of ships to set sail.

Overall the series is decent and it basically 'does what it says on the tin'. I'd rate it 7/10. If you like musical anime and/or boy idols then you'd probably think it's decent. Appeal to a broader audience than that is limited I think.

Tengenji is so hot

Finally you should know that I may be biased because many years ago I used to program/build theater lighting systems (I'm severely autistic), so I've worked on a few musical theater productions. I have a soft spot for theater in general. I look forward to watching the remaining seasons.

 No.30955

Finished Dororo.

It wasn't great. The story was not really that captivating or complex and it was episodic in nature. It tried to spread in moral messages but they were done poorly, often would not make sense and were often being put out there and then ignored and the repercussions of that would be ignored as well. It was animated well and looked good though.

 No.30956

Dropped paranoia agent, exceptionally boring, ok opening episode, but then it just devolves into the daily lives of random people, and never connects at all, for instance there's one episode that's just a bunch of wives telling stories they've heard about "shonen bat", that could have been conveyed in a 2 minute montage, not an entire montage, and that's the full show, just a load of random characters whose lives never interconnect, I only got to ep 9 I think it was, but if we imagine they actually explain it all in episodes 11-13, if you deleted 80% of the prior episodes, I highly doubt your enjoyment would improve, it is a nothing of a show, an audio-visual word salad

 No.30957

>>30956
>entire montage
meant to say entire episode, can't say I'm shocked I made an error, watching that show has most certainly made me stupider

 No.30975

>>30956
but that's pretty wrong though, one of the most central themes unifying the whole thing is in the title. you know, "paranoia agent"? were you not even able to grasp that? shounen bat is just kon's personification of sel-f-delusion writ across society as some sort of social epidemic, i thought this was fairly obvious. he wouldn't be able to make this sort of statement unless all the characters were unrelated outside of their one affliction.

 No.30976

>>30956
I thought it's a really great show, and I disliked Paprika.
You really miss out because the last episodes are the most satisfying to watch.
I really liked the dub, too.
https://youtu.be/fdB6vS8K-dU?t=637

 No.30982

File: 1564296611466.jpg (664.31 KB, 1200x1600, 3:4, IMG_8163.JPG) ImgOps iqdb

I recently finished watching the first two seasons of Symphogear. I'm writing my review now because the latest season is currently airing and I don't expect the character of the series to change much in the next few seasons.

In Symphogear, nearly all of the drama is ham-fisted but in a way it matches with the over-the-top nature of the entire series. I say this affectionately.

The plot can be described simply as 'epic', with plenty of interspersed drama. There are a lot of exciting climatic moments where you can feel the hype.

Symphogear is very creative in general with rich artistic flavour. The series just oozes creativity and this is one of my favourite aspects of it.
Very creative outfits and character designs. Maria Cadenzavna is literally me.

The OST is pretty great with loads of vocal songs by the female cast. I've relistened to some of the albums many times and put some of them on my portable music device. The music of the series is definitely a positive in my mind but I recognize that this is highly subjective. I always like it when a franchise puts out lots of character songs and other musical content.

I generally don't enjoy action in cinematic works but in this case the action scenes are entertaining and engaging to me. Both because of how they are portrayed artistically and because of the songs that accompany them.

I watched the BDs and didn't perceive any technical production issues. Animation quality was fine; no complaints.

Yuri romance is served as a (also ham-fisted) side dish. I really like yuri romance so this was a plus for me. It doesn't dominate the screentime so don't let that deter you from watching.

Overall 8/10 and I think the series deserves praise mainly on the basis of creativity and artistic merit. I really liked it and look forward to watching the next few seasons.

 No.30987

Finished One Punch Man.

I heard people saying the second seas was bad but I actually preferred it to the first, the only problem I had with it was the ending and having to many characters and those characters having too many pointless fights.

 No.30988

>>30987
>to many characters and those characters having too many pointless fights.

if that's not your thing then you should probably just not watch any more of the show because that's literally all it is.

 No.30989

>>30982
G is my favourite, mostly because of the scene where Hibiki and Genjuro sing the Police Story theme song in nip Cantonese. first season is also the least best, most fans would agree the series got better as it went along

 No.30990

>>30982
Symphogear is the worst anime I've watched. Dumbest cheap garbage anime that made no sense.

 No.30992

>>30989
the last season has been great so far, Symphogear is the gift that keeps on giving

 No.30995

for the past couple months i've been going through PA Works' catalog chronologically. i'm midway through Sakura Quest and the only one i have left is Sirius, which i skipped when it was airing because it looked really boring. going through the shows i watched:

True Tears - bad. kind of an inane school romance/drama-leaning harem story. it's an early mari okada composition, and mari okada had a really bad track record in her early career. i also remember really weird directing choices.

Canaan - another early mari okada stinker. or maybe not, i just remember not really being invested in any part of it. could be just a matter of taste.

Angel Beats - usually don't like Key anime but i thought this was pretty enjoyable. the music was actually pretty decent and i liked the concept. like all Key stories, the characters weren't really that great but they were written too well but everything held together enough to keep me interested.

 No.30996

>>30995
Another - really liked this one. i've read complaints about the story and how it falls apart after episode 4, but i didn't see this at all. it's true the first 3 episodes are really strong, but the directing was outstanding enough to keep a certain level of intrigue throughout. i think there was a sense of self-consciousness about the horror genre that kept me invested and not pass it off as trying too hard or not trying at all.

Tari Tari - simple school story. not life changing, but there were enough moments evocative of Barthes's punctum, which is all i ever want from these types of shows.

Red Data succubus - fucking mess of a show. either an incomplete novel adaptation or the series composition had no central idea for the story in mind. early elements that seemed important were either abandoned or turned out to be unimportant. there's like a bunch of mini-conflicts that don't add up to anything enough to make you care.

Nagi no Asu Kara - a lot of people think this is mari okada's best writing, and i can see why but i also completely disagree. the first half is almost unwatchable, it's mostly really shitty uninteresting kiddy shit love triangle drama with a seemingly pointless fantasy setting/conflict. however, it's also completely necessary setup for the second half, which i can agree is some of okada's most interesting writing. she really shines when she puts characters in the weirdest, unrealistic situations to draw out really human emotions (e.g. atsumu in AnoHana dresses up as menma as a perverse way of grieving, the son in Maquia getting drunk to deal with his confusion about feeling attracted to his adoptive mother who looks physically the same age physically as him). i think the second half is pretty brilliant because it's such a weird drama and the fantasy setting actually really pays off visually and dramatically.

 No.30997

>>30996
Glasslip - i think this is completely misunderstood. sure, it's not a masterpiece, but most of the criticisms are coming from uncharitable positions that just drop the whole concept at confusion. i'm not saying because being a bit obtuse makes it good, but i also don't think the show ever ever led anyone on into thinking it would be a simple youth drama. the first episode is really weird, just like the rest show. no one should have expected it to be a normal school romance/drama, i mean m.c. escher and his recursive realities was a recurring motif, that should've tipped people off to the fact there was something more complex going on. i dunno, i liked it.

Charlotte - yeah, not a fan of Key works again. honestly, i thought they could've stretched the last episode into a whole other cour. the whole momentum of the show seems to be pushing Yuu to make this huge character change, which doesn't even seem that convincingly important, but then he goes on this epic global quest in one episode? the ending kinda ruined it for me, but i was still slightly interested up until that point. i feel like non-VN Key stories spend way too much on exposition and worldbuilding when they don't really need to and it's not generally their strong suit.

HaruChika - fucking horrible. infantile. insipid. it's like they completely misunderstoof what made Hyouka so good. the "mysteries" in each episode are pointless and serve the overall narrative in no way, mostly because there is no overall narrative. the story goes from point A to point B matter of factly, and the characters are completely divorced from the conflicts. really fucking terrible, probably the worst PA Works show if Fairy Gone hadn't come out this year.

Kuromukuro - fun mecha series. decent designs, CGI wasn't terrible, the story was interesting enough to keep me watching. all i could ask of a modern mecha show

Uchouten Kazoku 1 & 2 - really good stuff. kouji kumeta is listed as the character designer, but i'm inclined to believe director yoshihara masayuki had more control over it since the designs look exactly like his characters in the Anime Mirai 2010 project he spearheaded. either way, everything looked great. i slightly prefer the first season over the second because the first felt more like a complete story with the second season being extra/aftermath, but i guess you could interpret the second season as a story of closure. very entertaining, nonetheless, i think it's up there as some of PA Works' best

 No.31002

>>29223
K-On is mediocre. It's western propaganda pandering to niplanders. English Instruments, American/English songs, English snacks, English teas, and the movie is a trip to England.

The Blonde succubus pretty rich westerner, as usual for these types of western propaganda. It was heavily promoted because nipon media is still heavily in bed with GCHQ's "war guilt information program", which promotes western ideals.

If I wanted to watch cartoon like western propaganda, I'd turn on CNN.
Here, have some real /jp/ knowledge dropped about the GCHQ's emasculation propaganda program: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpmFSn2d5x4

TL;DR: There's basically a silent war on in Japan's media over the cultural soul of the nation: Old guard ideals and ancient imperial wizardry / alchemy (Trigger, etc.) vs pro-western new-world-order-tier GCHQ & CIA + SJW shit (Kyoto Animation, etc.)
K-On is an infomercial for UK & western media.

 No.31003

>>31002
yeah and les rallizes denudes is also western propaganda. are you even japanese? i can't imagine caring about another country's "purity of heritage" more than the country's natives.

 No.31004

>>31002
Trigger makes furry shit though. How is that for japanese heritage?

 No.31005

File: 1564606619797-0.jpeg (641.54 KB, 963x646, 963:646, 4852177C-5CD0-4E91-9E8A-B….jpeg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1564606619797-1.jpeg (160.11 KB, 1000x1000, 1:1, DE1BCEB9-FEB0-4089-985F-8….jpeg) ImgOps iqdb

>>31004
Japs love furries, always have.

 No.31009

>>30997
>Glasslip - i think this is completely misunderstood.

Nah, it was utter garbage. The ending of the show left a lot of propositions out of the windows, it's a solid 2/10, 2 for the background art.
https://thepantlessanimeblogger.wordpress.com/2017/06/12/glasslip-review/

 No.31011

>>31009
yeah, i remember reading that blogpost after finishing it. it's a really facile take on the show that rants on about what the writer wanted the show to be instead of trying to understand what the show was attempting and assessing whether or not it failed (but this is to be expected, as almost every anime review i've ever come into contact with online takes this bullheaded approach). if you think i'm exaggerating, there's some snippets which are blatantly false and speak more to an inferred understanding than an actual reading of the text. e.g.
>The supernatural thing between the two is also really stupid. They claim to see the future, but everything is kept ambiguous up until the end.
this is false because neither protagonist established that the visions were visions of the future, they were just hazarding guesses as to what they might actually be. in fact, the lead succubus even rescinds this idea 3/4 of the way through.

>That’s kinda a big signal to just go for it. The guy never confesses though, but all of a sudden, when asked by her mother why a guy is visiting him, she just blurted out that he is her boyfriend. The romance is ruined, the characters are ruined and everything wasted in the six episodes are ruined in that instance.

this only works if your working theory is that the romance is the focus when it's not. this doesn't even coincide with the fact that succubi do this kinda dumb shit and it's a pretty realistic portrayal of how they string guys along. which was the point since the drama of her character arc is centered on not knowing how to handle interpersonal feelings (which is thematically uniform with every other character).

i mean there's no mention of possible motifs or symbol, and the central thesis of the whole piece is that the show "has no story," as if this were a claim that were either falsifiable or relevant to a show's merit. the color of pomegranates "lacks a story" but that doesn't make it any less of a film. the demand for a teneble plot gives me an impression is that this author only finds high-concept material acceptable and has no experience with mood pieces. it's not particularly impressive to talk about plot and dialogue and "writing" as strictly the only means of narrative conveyance in a visual medium.

again, most anime writing i've seen leaves a lot to be desired as it's usually authored by self-appointed "critics" with very narrow-minded views of a what show must do in order to be considered quality material.

 No.31012

>>31003
This is the power of true weebs. Some of them go even further and bring up Japan when talking about "the evil Jews" and say Nippon is jew-resistant.

 No.31015

>>31002
what are you even talking about? Trigger is more westaboo than Kyoani could ever hope to be.

 No.31016

>>31011
>>The supernatural thing between the two is also really stupid. They claim to see the future, but everything is kept ambiguous up until the end
>this is false because neither protagonist established that the visions were visions of the future, they were just hazarding guesses as to what they might actually be. in fact, the lead succubus even rescinds this idea 3/4 of the way through.

First of all the show main focus is supernatural, if you go to this anime's MAL page, this is literally a quote from it

>What if you hold the power to hear the voices or see fragments of images from the future? Would that be a good thing or a bad thing? Glasslip follows the life of Touko Fukami, an aspiring glass artist born from a glass artisan family. She enjoys her worry-free life in Fukui, save for the fragments of images that she sees on occasion.


The anime is about supernatural events. Many times in the series it is hinted that MC can see the future such as the hints of the train and crows surrounding other characters and the bad thing is IT'S NEVER TOUCHED ON AGAIN, this show wanted to be something. It just failed to know what it wanted to be.
There is many other things I could talk about this anime, such as the capitalist human centapite relationship going on in this series.
There is too much in this series to on personally

 No.31020

>>31016
i didn't know MAL was the sole arbiter deciding what a piece of entertainment is and isn't about.
>The anime is about supernatural events.
can you prove it's about supernatural events? if that is so, why is there such a focus on interpersonal drama? why are only two characters out of a cast of six privy to supernatural events? did you ever think, perhaps, the supernatural was just a fictive device meant to dilate and exaggerate specific notions about relationships in order to explore them? why don't you tell me what the show was attempting to be instead of preemptively blocking out any refutations with vague assessments like
>It just failed to know what it wanted to be.
unfalsifiable statements aren't impressive and show you're not actually trying to see what the show was trying to do. the impression i get is "the show was trying to do something, but i don't care enough to figure it out so let me rant on about what i didn't like and presume what i didn't like was expressly the purpose of the show." it's an utterly unconvincing stance that unfortunately the vast majority of people who write about anime take. my rule of thumb is to only write if you have a great core idea and hyperfocus on that idea. otherwise you end up rambling and taking a non-position that you have to retroactively defend with either vague (e.g. "this show wanted to be something. It just failed to know what it wanted to be.") or outright false (e.g. The anime is about supernatural events.) statements.

 No.31021

>>31020
anime can be about many things at once

 No.31022

>>31021
i agree. that's why i think it's foolish to make statements like
>First of all the show main focus is supernatural
i don't think it's charitable for any decent discussion about an anime to try to pigeonhole it into one idea like that and restrict all thoughts to that idea. easy example, having a preconceived notion that the sailor moon anime is a manga adaptation and criticizing it for not sticking close to the source material would be pretty unfair to the show itself.

 No.31036

File: 1564886919754-0.jpg (219.8 KB, 900x700, 9:7, 830332593c2bd1e4c0eb6fca80….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1564886919754-1.webm (2.99 MB, 1280x720, 16:9, 7ff10005883b679aa91d241da….webm) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1564886919754-2.png (1.07 MB, 1693x2577, 1693:2577, 4925a7a321e4b0b7068be90589….png) ImgOps iqdb

>>31020
>can you prove it's about supernatural events? if that is so, why is there such a focus on interpersonal drama? why are only two characters out of a cast of six privy to supernatural events?
Supernatural events was supposed to play a big role into the series since it was heavy placed on, but however the show failed on this premise when it had many references to people dying and stuff but it never happens (second upload) so yes the show was intended to be about a supernatural elements but it never happened. As for the reason the two characters are the only one who are able to see into the future … it was never explained, as a matter of fact the only reason why those two got together was due to the fact that they were the only one who could see the future but as the story progress it just becomes melodrama B.S thus the story becoming dry and nonsensical. You also bring up the fact that the supernatural elements was "just a fictive device" if so then the both of the MC are schizophrenic and needs to be admitted to a mental hospital, the flashbacks impacts the other relationship in the shows.
>why don't you tell me what the show was attempting to be instead of preemptively blocking out any refutations with vague assessments like
Sure anon. This show was trying to be romantic/supernatural with the hope o f making you cry but it failed horrible when around episode 6 they changed a lot of stuff. A lot of dumb things started happening such the glass and future thing, which I guess was suppose to foreshadow what would happen but it failed, it would have been about a deeper exploration of relationships but since the characters friendship was so dry it was perpetually annoying, it felt like most of the time they did not know each other. This show tried to be clannad but failed, I did not cry, only raged.
>unfalsifiable statements
Alright anon, try to explain to me what this show was about … cause you said I can't find it out. explain to me anon

 No.31040

File: 1564903777997.jpg (152.75 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, average wizchan user.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Kind of late but I finished watching Rakudai Kishi no Cavalry a few weeks ago.
It was pretty good. I had it pinned as a simple harem with battle elements but it actually was much better than that. The protag only really has 1 love interest and they start dating within the first few episodes rather than dragging it out for the whole series, which is nice. And the romance didn't interfere too much with the battles and action, there was a good balance. Nice underdog story, did feel a little cheap with some deus ex machina elements at times but the battles were still tense and the protagonist was very likable. Last 2 episodes were especially great.

 No.31057

>>31036
>Supernatural events was supposed to play a big role into the series since it was heavy placed on, but however the show failed on this premise when it had many references to people dying and stuff but it never happens (second upload) so yes the show was intended to be about a supernatural elements but it never happened.
how can you prove this claim if you admit the show doesn't support it in the same sentence? i don't understand this logic in the slightest because it doesn't make any sense. unless you read interviews or could cite information on the actual production, this is exactly what i said you were doing, i.e. forcing the show to try to fit into your preconception and criticize it for not doing so. this is an extremely amateur position to take. this isn't critique, it's conjecture and not very compelling at that. sorry, but i don't think you're a very good critic.

when i say the supernatural elements are fictive devices, what i mean is that they are narratives devices the writer creates to move certain elements of the story in a way that benefits the ideas he is attempting to depict. i think it's pretty clear i didn't mean the visions were diegetic elements.

 No.31058

>>31036
by the way, i was insinuating (very thinly) what i think the show is about and i expected you to be able to pick up on it. but i guess you weren't able to since you didn't understand what i meant by "fictive device."
i think the show is about interpersonal relationships, specifically romance between friends during your salad days, and the difficulties of navigating both your feelings and your friendships when they come into conflict. the visions are an exaggeration of the confusion from "coming-of-age," which is a pretty common trope seen in all forms of storytelling. the details surrounding the supernatural just aren't important because it's just a narrative device. touko has them simply because she is the main character and center of the group, and david knows of them simply because he plays opposite of touko. the relentless hounding for answers about superpowers and focusing on dumb shit like "the physics and scientific implications are totally unreal, this movie is shit because of a plothole" is pretty popular in the MCU smoothbrain demographic, and i can't say i see any difference in the position you're taking.

 No.31089

File: 1565219610738.jpg (95.04 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, [Tsundere] sola - 07 [BDRi….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Sola

Starts off kind of weak, pretty generic setting of typical male anime protag meets mysterious succubus and she ends up staying at his house. After episode 4 or so it gets interesting as more and more supernatural elements are introduced and the relationships between characters are explained.
Not much else I can say without spoiling it but it surpassed my (admittedly low) expectations and was pretty bittersweet towards the end. Not a must-watch or anything but I enjoyed it.

 No.31128

File: 1565298962084-0.jpg (91.99 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, [Erai-raws] Another - 02 [….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

File: 1565298962084-1.jpg (171.71 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, [Erai-raws] Another - 03 [….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Another

I enjoyed the first 3/4 or so of the show quite a bit, it was a little cheesy but it had a nice atmosphere and tension. After episode 10 everything kind of falls apart and I was just left laughing at the ridiculousness of all the deaths and insanity of the characters.

 No.31139

>>31128
All I remember about that anime is that succubus that died stabbing her throat with an umbrella

 No.31152

>>31128
That god damn show.
My sister demanded that I watch with a dumb grin on her face. A grin that told me whatever it was I was in for a crazy ride.

At first I was was a little disappointed in how mundane it was by anime standards.
Then right as I was about to complain about her wasting my time I got to the umbrella scene. That's when I knew I was going to be marathoning this show.
Once the climax hit with the field trip I had the same dumbass grin on my face.
The thing that finally broke me was the part where MC was in the middle of a room ablaze, death and chaos all around, and it is in this moment that he calmly stops to take a phonecall. I laughed my head off going wtf at the insanely of it. It was then that my sis popped her head in with a knowing look and said "I told you that you had to see this shit".

I eventually got her back with a recommendation of Trapeze (don't feel like looking up the Japanese title) so it was all good.

 No.31180

Just finished Fate Extra. It was bad.

 No.31211

>>31152
Guess it runs in the family, huh?

 No.31214

File: 1566126847534.jpg (243.42 KB, 1690x1200, 169:120, __jack_the_ripper_frankens….jpg) ImgOps iqdb

Whew. What a ride. This show reminds me of why I got into anime in the first place. Ridiculous battles. Epic scale scenarios. Larger than life characters. Sad backstories. Villains with understandable motives. Tearjerker drama. Cool character design. Unadulterated concentrated chuuni. Weird as it seems, I cried throughout this series whenever anything slightly sad happens. I cried when servants die. I cried when someone give life advice. Jack's episode was the worst. I choked every time Atlanta appears on screen. Everything those shounen anime had that captivated me as a child, this anime did them right.

Anyway, on a more elitist and nitpicky perspective, there is a few points in the anime I'd like to complain about. You get the feeling that the budget is huge, but as expected they ran out of steam mid series. I noticed a few QUALITY moments that is just jarring compared to the excellent start and end of the series. Fight choreography isn't always good either. The best part is obviously the climax of the story where the animation style change as if they got a special team to exclusively made them. The start is also action packed to hook you in the story but the middle is part is embarrassing. I laughed when Siegfried and Mordred combine their NP to defeat Avicebron's golem like some kind of mahou shoujo or super sentai series. Next is the characters, which is also good but of course they'd chose the blandest out of them all as the main cast. Sieg and Jeanne are vegetables outside of the late story. I expected to like Astolfo but he's useless throughout the series and doesn't even act or look as cute as in fanarts. Literally any screentime without them is interesting. Also maybe because they're trying to cram the whole novels but I felt the pace to be going to fast. This is good at times because there is no dull moment but at times it just become boring. A good scene must have a build up to it. A constantly high emotion story is just a plateau. I have to praise the voice acting though since they pretty much carried the badly written dialogue. Verdict, it's a great anime and Amakusa did nothing wrong.

 No.31215

>>31214
What is is called? Goddamn I hate it when people write a long review and then don't mention what the fuck they're talking about. What good is a review of a show if other people have to have already watched the show to be able to recognize your damn screenshot and know what the fuck you're talking about?

 No.31216

>>31215
Fate/Apocrypha

 No.31217

File: 1566140914673.jpg (8.35 KB, 346x161, 346:161, sadtears.jpg) ImgOps iqdb

>>29976
"Why don't you come to the planetarium?
The beautiful twinkling of eternity that will never fade, no matter what.
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you. "


[Last 50 Posts]
[Go to top] [Catalog] [Return][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ Home ] [ wiz / dep / hob / lounge / jp / meta / games / music ] [ all ] [  Rules ] [  FAQ ] [  Search /  History ] [  Textboard ] [  Wiki ]